Showing posts with label evolution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label evolution. Show all posts

Thursday, August 13, 2026

Father Time: A Natural History of Men and Babies

Father Time: A Natural History of Men and Babies by Sarah Blaffer Hrdy

Fathers play some role in nurturing their young. This book explores that by grabbing facts from all across humanity and the animal kingdom. It appears to be reaching for any example it can find, rather than having a coherent narrative. There is still debate over the physical vs. social reasons for men and woman's role in caring for children. There doesn't seem to be any strong conclusion here.

Friday, November 01, 2024

Goodness Paradox

The Goodness Paradox: The Strange Relationship Between Peace and Violence in Human Evolution by Richard Wrangham

People are good, but not good. Humans have domesticated themselves, and in the process have come to dominate. Some cultures can appear to be so peace-loving, but also very violent. The death penalty may have curtailed many of the most violent tendencies in society. Homo sapiens have had more feminine influences and less violence.

This book is a hodgepodge of ideas and studies that explore peace and violence. The history of humanity is explored as well as comparisons of other animals. Chimpanzees can be very violent, but Bonobos are much more peaceful. A number of theories are tossed around, but we don't seem to be at a point where one can be declared the best.

Thursday, June 13, 2024

Natural Theology or Evidences of the Existence and Attributes of the Deity

Natural Theology or Evidences of the Existence and Attributes of the Deity by William Paley

William Paley took a look at nature and determined that there was so much organized complexity that their had to be a creator. This book then goes into extreme detail of everything that was observed. We hear about different functionality in animals, from the way they move to consume their senses. The structure of the arguments are similar to modern intelligent design arguments against evolution. However, this book was written before Darwin was even born. Were the evolution arguments written in response to these arguments? 

Wednesday, May 15, 2024

How Life Works: A User’s Guide to the New Biology

How Life Works: A User’s Guide to the New Biology by Philip Ball

Everything you thought you knew about biology is wrong - or at least inadequate to explain how things work. Biology had drifted towards a "genetic determinism" approach. It was assumed that genes were like computer programs. If we understood the genes we could understand everything. We could just manipulate the "code" to get any desire we wanted. However, biology is not that deterministic. 

It was thought that DNA is primarily for coding proteins. Non-coding DNA was seen as "junk" that may have held a legacy purpose, but is not useful today. However, it is not that simple. Much of that non-coding DNA has distinct purposes that define how organisms develop and behave. 

In general, genes are probabilistic, not deterministic. There are many factors in play. Cells are often guided by neighboring cells in their behavior. Epigenetics, neighboring genes and environmental conditions all can play a role in development. When comparing life to computers, it is much more like a learning model than a predefined algorithm. Or perhaps we could consider it more like the development of an unplanned city vs. central planning. There is simply a lot we don't understand and probably a lot more "chance" involved than we have suspected.

Saturday, March 09, 2024

Catching Fire: How Cooking Made Us Human

Catching Fire: How Cooking Made Us Human by Richard Wrangham

Humans adopted cooking. Then evolution move to favor those that cooked food. Cooking food allowed humans to devote fewer resources to the digestive system and more to other areas. This helped humans to later dominate. Today there are some people that advocate "raw" diets. However, these diets are rare and often result in caloric deficiencies. They also often require use of food that has been processed in some ways. Humanity's ancestors were likely able to live on this raw food, but today, people are quick to move towards cooking.

Wednesday, November 02, 2022

A Brief History of Everyone Who Ever Lived: The Human Story Retold Through Our Genes

We can learn a lot about history by looking at DNA sequences. Advances in technology make it much easier to sequence DNA that we can find in long-dead remains.  Other "human-like" species have existed and mated with humans, yet they no longer exist today. However, there are still traces of their genetic materials. Europeans and Asians have some Neanderthal genetic material, yet Africans seem to lack it. We can even analyze the distribution to determine which side tended to be females and male in the early mating. 

This book is a discussion about what our genes can and cannot tell us. A lot of what we can know involves comparing DNA to known sources. What we have trouble knowing is the impact certain genes have on individuals. The news will often report that scientists have discovered a gene for a certain trait. However, this simply indicates there is a statistical relationship between the gene and trait. It may be fairly useless. A large percentage of incarcerated people may have a gene. Yet, if the gene is also prevalent in a large percentage of free people, it doesn't tell us much. Genes will often work together with other genes making it unlikely a single gene will indicate much. We can consider this the start of scientific research rather than the end.

Saturday, April 30, 2022

The Sixth Extinction: An Unnatural History

There is a base way of extinction that happens as part of evolutionary systems. There are also extreme factors that contribute to mass-extinction events. Mankind is contributing to one of the newest mass events. Climate is changing so fast that habitats become inhabitable before species can adapt. Species can also fall prey to encroachment of habitats (via farming, cities, roadways or other modern development). The rapid movement of goods and people has also contributed to mass events. (White nose powder fungus contributed to a mass kill-off of bats. This may have spread rapidly by humans faster than bats could evolve defenses.) There are also cases of animals have evolved with minimal predators and thus have been simply killed off by humans for meat or sport.

The book mixes some general history of evolution with examples to raise the alarm about the negative impact of mankind on our world ecosystem. Evolution can lead to resilience. However, the species that are able to evolve the fastest are not necessarily the most beneficial. What are we to do?

Saturday, October 02, 2021

The Evolution of Everything: How New Ideas Emerge

Atheist Evolutionary Predestined Libertarianism. That pretty much sums up the Ridley's principles. He is advocating the opposite of the "great man" view of history. Everything was destined to happen. Some people may slow progress through their interventions, but can do little to help things along. The best course of action is for government and culture to get out of the way and let things happen. 

Areas that have the most government involvement (such as education and healthcare) tend to stagnate, with cost going up without significant innovation. The background on education is quite interesting. Private education was taking off in a big way in the United States. However, people saw what was going on in Prussia and decided that would be a good model. (The Prussians were upset about the condition of their troops, so they wanted to train them to be high quality conformists ready to fight.) This manner of education continues to serve as our basic model. When asking for funding, the education establishment will bring about the need to teach people basic skills. However, that could be carried out much more effectively for a small fraction of the cost. What public education really provides is indoctrination. The goal is for students to have the appropriate beliefs that the current establishment desires. The education institutions also have a vested interest in protecting their jobs and continue their rent seeking behavior. Instead of keeping the ossified structure in place, we should let it continue to evolve to better provide for students. (Even formal private education is often over-regulated today.)

There are often many bad policies put in place as the elite tries to "help" others like the poor. They assume that they know what other people need and want, so they mandate it, rather than let things evolve. Zoning regulations were put in place to separate living conditions from jobs. Parking requirements, floor area ratios and other regulations were put in place to provide ideal living conditions. Isn't it ironic, they people still flock to live in old parts of cities that did not adhere to those regulations? If we just let things evolve, some might be that way. But others would not. Government gets in the way. We try to guess how things will turn out, but really only slow things down. Children are most influences by their genes and their peers. I guess that gives parents a role in picking a location for their peers. But, most of the future will just "evolve".

Thursday, May 13, 2021

The Story of the Human Body: Evolution, Health, and Disease

The human body has evolved in a different environment than it exists in today. We have many innovations that make our life "easier" today. However, these same innovations also take away some of the needed stresses that help our body body to properly develop and fight of ailments. 

The book starts with the origins of humans. Early hominids started to walk upright millions of years ago. This created many challenges, but also gave some advantages. (After all, they did not become extinct.) Brain size also increase. (There is still debate as to what caused what.) Eventually, homo sapien spread across the world, primarily as a hunter-gatherer society.

The human body is fairly well optimized for hunting and gathering life. This type of life required a great deal of physical exercise. It also required a lot of chewing (Which helped lead to good dental appearance.) Sweet food was prized and stored up. Humans store more fat than many other animals, giving advantages in survival. People have infrequent births, but a higher likelihood of a child living longer. Birthing is not easy. However, the wider hips allow for larger babies to be born, though they still need more attention after birth.

Our ailments today often come from "too much" or "too little". We have processed food to give us the primary energy that we crave. Our genes encourage us to stock up on this food and store it away. Alas, this lead to obesity and a number of other ailments. On the too little side, we don't move enough. Our bones and muscles are strengthened by stresses. 

Our medical system focuses on treating symptoms rather than making lifestyle changes to reduce causes. This has inadvertently resulted in some negative evolution of disease. Social evolution has a curious interaction with different conditions. (Is near-sightedness more common because of related benefits? Or is it because it has little harm and is easily fixed?) Many diseases today also appear later in life, causing little negative pressure on reproduction.  

Looking at the "long" picture provides an interesting insight into the human condition as well as some concerns about the way we are practicing medicine today.

Sunday, March 28, 2021

The Rational Optimist: How Prosperity Evolves

Humans have come to dominate the world through innovation. People can build upon knowledge and others' work to create new things. Even something simple like a pencil is behind the scope of any single person to easily create on their own. They would need to cut down trees, mine metal, and do all the work to shape and form it. It would be a daunting task. Today it is easy to buy a pencil at the local store. Many people have been involved in the process to make the pencil, yet they  don't have the knowledge and skills outside their realm.

The author has great faith in the ability of humans to innovate their way out of problems. However, he has little faith in us being able to predict what innovations will take place. He sees government intervention as often a fools errand. Subsidizing big companies that were previous innovators merely delays their eventual fall. The smaller, newer, more nimble organizations are the ones that provide most of the advantage to society. These small companies then become big ones and often ossify. Governments tend to favor them because they are big, yet that is a mistake. Governments also attempt to regulate activities based on what is currently known. This can interfere with truly useful innovations. Many of the problems in poor countries can be traced to rent-seeking leaders. The institutions are corrupt making it difficult for anything to get done. Even with foreign aid, the poor often remain poor, while the leaders are getting rich.

The author has little respect for pessimist alarmists. Negative fear-mongering does get a lot of coverage. He catalogs big fears such as "overpopulation", "acid rain" and "global cooling" that have all fallen by the wayside. Today, "global warming" is the boogeyman. He acknowledges that the earth is warming, but objects to many of the actions that are taken. Climate change will cause changes. However, humans have always dealt with climatic changes, and could continue to deal with it. Even in some of the worse case scenarios, the total risk is not worth significant societal changes. 

The "fixes" can be worse than the problem. Some of the "renewable" resources such as biofuels require great amounts of land and can be a net negative for climate change. Even "green energy" like wind is very inefficient. Legislation often greatly subsidizes forms of "green" energy production we know about, which my stall some of the needed innovation. Fossil fuels are amazingly efficient and have replaced previous forms of energy (such as slaves and animals). They have also long outlasted their predicted depletion thanks to increases in extraction and usage efficiency. We likely have a solution to our energy problems waiting to be created. The solution probably is not something that we think of (electric or self-driving cars), but instead something totally new.

Is there a limit to how we can innovate out of our problems? Yes. This has been seen in previous cultures. In the middle ages, both China and the Muslim chose stability over innovation. Government policies have often forced innovation down the wrong track. Perhaps we will run into something that we just can't make better. However, if we do, government will not be able to help us.

Saturday, February 13, 2021

The Red Queen: Sex and the Evolution of Human Nature

The Red Queen hypothesis comes from the character in Lewis Carrol's Through the Looking Glass who is always running in order to keep in the same place. Sexual selection must be used as part of the mechanism to continually evolve and adapt in order to stave off extinction. The book starts by asking "why sex?" It seems a very inefficient way to pass on genes. After all, why not just clone oneself to pass on all genes? There are many theories. The "change" is a key benefit. There are chances to clean up "mistakes" or introduce "new mistakes". It also encourages social behaviors. Different animals have adapted in various ways due to their mating patterns. Sex selection also happens in various manners (sometimes based on things such as temperature.) Humans are rather unique in not knowing the precise time of fertility and not producing off-spring that are "done" yet. (The "big brains" need to fit through the small birth canal.) People seem to have an in-built incest restriction against mating with people we have grown up with. Other mating rules have differed across cultures. Monogamy has become a common way to ensure the child has two parents to help with raising. Polygamy may benefit a few men at the top of the hierarchy, but in general it benefits women who now have greater access to the alphas. Men seek traits in women that allow for the production of more offspring (such as youth.)

There are many interesting theories put out and discarded in the book. The book even ends admitting that much of what is written will be proven wrong. Humans have adapted quite well to dominate the current world. Will we continue to do so?

Wednesday, January 27, 2021

The Secret of Our Success: How Culture Is Driving Human Evolution, Domesticating Our Species, and Making Us Smarter

The Secret of Our Success explores the importance of cultural evolution in the success of homo sapiens. The book also explores the ways in which cultural evolution can synergisticly work with genetic evolution.

The social aspect of culture can be compared somewhat to moving work to the cloud. On one side, you can get more and more powerful computers. However, you can also combine many smaller computers together to achieve similar results. Combining the smaller computers also allows for more resiliency and rapid expansion. The culture can provide similar benefits. We don't need to re-learn what foods are safe and how to prepare them. Our culture is built on previous discoveries. Today we have tools and technologies built on top of many levels of previous ones.

This does have some challenges. As isolated societies grow smaller, they can lose cultural knowledge. There are also challenges when certain knowledgeable people are lost. (There is an example of a society that lost its kyak builders.) 

Skin color is an interesting example of cultural and genetic evolution working in tandem. Darker skin is beneficial in warmer, sunnier climates. In more northerly climates, paler skin allows for more vitamin D formation and is beneficial for farming societies. However, Inuit societies are able to obtain the needed vitamins from the animals they consume in the arctic. Thus, the lighter skin is not as beneficial. We see cultural and genetic needs working in tandem.

Norms and goals are important. Societies have different languages, taboos and ways of doing things. They are often adopted based on observance of "models".  Often these norms are based on some need that is now no longer understood. There are often seemingly "odd" behaviors that were built on a social requirement. (For example, food may be prepared in certain ways to provide needed nutrition.) There can also be cultural norms that were merely adopted based on models without any useful requirements. Different languages result in different types of communications. Some also have a sound structure that is optimized for the particular environment.

Cultural evolution became an integral part of human evolution. We have trouble surviving individually without our culture. Even eating is dependent on cultural learning. Our digestive system is not optimized for eating available raw foods. We need cooking and other processing for most of our eating. Genetic evolution has worked in tandem with the cultural evolution to optimize for the beneficial genes and let redundant ones to fade out. We don't need to rely on one individual brain, but can take knowledge from society past and present.

Thursday, May 30, 2019

Humanimal

Humanimal looks at humans from an "animal" perspective. How is it that humans came to dominate the world? Use of tools helped, but many other animals have tools. The ability to pass on knowledge from generation to generation ends up being a main factor. He spends a good chunk of time looking at corollary behaviors in other animals. He cautions that people should not justify a human behavior simply because a similar behavior exists in nature. Animals may appear to rape and murder, but without a communicable thought process, there is no way to directly compare. He also spends time looking at sexual behaviors. There are a number of different reproductive mechanisms out there. There are also many instances of animals (including humans) engaging in sexual activity that will not produce offspring. Why is that so? There are some conclusions to that and the question of how homosexuality propagates. He dubunks many explanations, and cautiously presents his preferred explanations. (For example, homosexuals tend to come from larger families.) There are some areas that he decides are not worth touching, and just condemns them out of hand. There are some interesting bits, but it is overall an easily forgettable book.

Saturday, October 27, 2018

Close Encounters with Humankind

Close Encounters with Humankind is a book of paleoanthropologic essays that originally appeared in a Korean magazine. The explore the evolution of man and the nearest relatives. Man is unique among other animals in that language is used extensively to pass on long term knowledge. The role of fathers and grandparents also sets humans apart from other animals. With most animals, mothers tend to have sole responsibility for raising the young. However, human fathers stay around. Longer lifespans have also allowed grandparents to continue to play a role.
Evolution and culture have worked together to help bring about change among humans. Tightly packed cities have allowed for greater sharing of knowledge and talents. It has also allowed greater numbers of diseases to spread. Agriculture has been arguable one of the greatest and worst things to happen to humankind. It allowed the growth of culture and cities. It allowed or a rapid population boom. It also allowed for property ownership, war and disease. Similar to the transportation and communication improvements of today, there are great costs of the great advancements.

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Origins of the Human Mind Part 2


This is the second part of the lectures. The focus here seems to be on diseases and the nature vs. nurture debate. There seem to be more questions than answers. And even the answers can be ambiguous. In nature vs. nurture, the answer seems to be "both". Genes can set somebody up in a path. The environment can help trigger the action based on the genetic structure. However, there are many genes for each condition, and most things require a bit of each.
As for diseases, there is a lot of subjectivity as to what is a disease and what is not. There is also the issue of "continuous" or "discrete". For many things, an arbitrary point on a continuum is considered "disease". Is this accurate? What makes something a disease versus a simple deviance from the norm. Big changes in cases of mental disease seem to be more closely related to the redefining of what is disease rather than actual changes in society. Some mental diseases are also more present in certain types of society. (ADHD for instance is common when students are stuck in sedentary learning environments. It is not so much an issue when they are out on a hunt.)
There are also questions as to how mental illness was propagated in society. One possible explanation is that a heterozygous gene provides benefits, while homozygous could have the disease. However, many mental problems occur due to complex interactions of multiple genes and the environment. It could be that some mental issues were actually benefits, or that some aspects of the mental problem were beneficial and only become problems when combined with others.

The lectures provide some interesting material and a lot to think about. While it does touch on origins, this would be more accurately title "Mental Illness: What is it and where did it come from"

Tuesday, November 01, 2011

Origins of the Human Mind part one



delves in to details about the human mind. It begins by presenting some different means of looking at the mind (from completely chemical to completely ethereal.) Currently, a mixed view is most common.

The lectures spend a lot of time covering the physiology and chemical reactions that help the brain to work. This provides some background for explaining the causes of some mental disorders (and why certain drugs like Ritalin work by stimulating rather than depressing.) Psychological analysis (and even Freud) are also brought in to the picture.

The lectures were engaging, yet this first part seems to be primarily about dumping out factoids related to a lot of material.

Friday, August 27, 2010

Darwanism and the Modern World

Evolution and It's Discontents: Darwin, Darwinism and the Modern World (Portable Professor)
The delivery of these lectures has something to be desired. Even at double speed it is still very sloooow. The content is fairly basic. It starts with a little of Darwin's biography and the days that he lived. (Then, most scientists were non-professional "lay-people". It then proceeds to give a basic explanation of the theory of natural selection. The most intriguing part was the section on the responses to Darwin's theories. Genetics, though now seen to go hand-in-hand with evolution was seen to disprove Darwinism. Religion at first got on fine with evolutionary theory, while science seemed to voice the most objections.

The lectures close with some of the contemporary issues in evolution, from internal challenges (such as "selfish gene") to external challenges (such as creationism). In all, its a decent, simple, non-technical introduction to evolutionary thought.

Thursday, August 26, 2010

The Politically Incorrect Guide to Darwinism and Intelligent Design


I wasn't expecting much from this book on Intelligent Design. From what I'd heard, ID was just a watered down version of creationism - and the PI guide series tends to be filled with right wing rants. I was, however, pleasantly surprised.
"Darwinist" thought has dominated biological discussion and taken credit for most of the advancement in biology. This book pokes holes in some of those arguments. Many advancements in biology have occurred without regard to Darwinist thought. Even when evolutionary principles are involved, they are usually micro-evolution principles - principles that do have real world proof. (Intelligent Design advocates agree with these ideas.)
The author points out that Darwinist "macro-evolution" of species generation has rarely (if ever) been seen "live."
Also, while "Darwinists" often criticize Intelligent-Design advocates as merely propagating religion, many of the most ardent Darwinists are also ardent atheists (such as Richard Dawkins). Their pushing of Darwinism is tightly couple with a "religious" viewpoint.
In the end, religion is probably the only thing that can settle the evolution debate. Even Darwin has admitted that the geological record has problems. Without some sort of divine intervention it will be impossible to definitively determine the origins.
The funny thing is that despite the rhetoric, it probably doesn't matter very much to biology whether life was "designed" or purely "evolved". Even literal creationists give the world at least a few thousand years of age - which would still allow for substantial "evolution" to occur after creation.
The big problem with intelligent design is the difficulty society has with religion. Years ago, laws prohibited the teaching of evolution in favor of creation. Now that Darwinists have the law on their side, they seek to prohibit anything other than Darwinism. A better balance would be to allow all possibilities to be taught. After all, even Darwin was an advocate of pangenesis and other "consensus" theories that have been debunked. Silencing "unproven" theories just because they go against the orthodoxy could merely be seen as another form of "religion".

Monday, May 17, 2010

Kluge


The human brain is a haphazard kluge that often does things that do not now appear to be in its best interest. The rational brain can be subverted through framing, short term appeals, or even momentary blips. This book provides evolutionary explanations for some of this behavior, along with plenty of examples of the kluges in action.

I found the book interesting at first, but the later chapters became more difficult to slog through. The book seemed to lose focus, and simply repeat the same generalities from a different view. The author's spurious attacks on creationism became tedious and distracting. (The typical attack: "the human mind is not perfect, therefore there could not have been a creator." Hmmm. does that I could not have possibly created some software because it has bugs? Well, looking at some code, maybe it did just randomly evolve.)

At the end, the book transforms itself in to a "self-help" book, summarizing the book by presenting 13 methods for "coping" with the brain kluges. (Well, at least the major ones. There isn't a section on popping pills to cope with psychosis.) The book would almost work better backwards. Read the coping methods, then scan the earlier part fro some of the good anecdotes, skipping over some of the 'kulgey' writing.