Showing posts with label libertarian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label libertarian. Show all posts

Sunday, May 05, 2024

The Machinery of Freedom: Guide to a Radical Capitalism

The Machinery of Freedom: Guide to a Radical Capitalism by David D. Friedman

This book has a number of small chapters exploring an extreme libertarianism. The start focuses on changes that can be done to our society to get here. He observes that government has problems with prioritization and influence. Even policies as innocuous as social security end up taking from the poor to give to the rich. (The rich start work later and live longer than the poor.)

The book was originally written in 1969, with some minor notes and updates in this third edition. Some things have changed since then. Other ideas have been sort of implemented, but twisted so much to make them unrecognizable. He proposed a "ride sharing" system as a solution to urban mobility. A jitney service would pair people heading towards a destination with those that need rides. This would provide low cost mobility for riders and minimal-effort extra income for drivers, all while reducing congestion.  This sounds just like the original vision of Uber and "ride-sharing" services. Alas, these services have morphed into unionized taxi services. Drivers have become quasi-employees that wait around explicitly to give rides to people. It makes traffic worse, and is more costly to all involved.

Government interference is a problem that continually grows. Parties may identify ways to benefit in the regulatory framework, resulting in new regulations to address those. Entrenched parties are reluctant to change. Teachers' unions are willing to advocate for increased education funding "in the name of the students". However, they are reluctant to advocate from an education system that eliminates their roles, even if that would really benefit students.

 There are frequently mismatches is the number and degree of benefit. Industries are significantly impacted by the regulations and take an active role in writing them, often to the detriment of individuals. The American Medical Association is given as an example. It is in their interest to make it harder to become a doctor. They also benefit by limiting access to other types of medicine. They have helped encourage the current drug and licensure system. The system is geared to minimizing harm, rather than maximizing benefit. A drug may be delayed because 2 people were harmed - even if that delay caused 2000 people to be harmed due to the lack of the drug. 

The end gets a little more modern. He ends the book with a discussion on schooling. He advocates unschooling - that way learning could be the focus rather than going through endless boredom and indoctrination. That also allows children to adopt more of culture from their parents instead of just from school.

He has arguments for just about any concern, from police force to military. There are also plenty of criticisms of government, regulation and democracy. Allowing everything to be bargained out would make things function ideally. However, the concern I see is that it would be a lot of work.  For those that are motivated, anarchy can be great. For those that just want to sit back and let life happen, haven government, unions and all the institutions may be easier. It will not get you the best results, but does not require work. Alas, I feel that the world today is dominated by the lazy.

Saturday, February 05, 2022

Believe in People: Bottom-Up Solutions for a Top-Down World

I often hear of the Koch brothers mentioned in the context of "radical right wing". When listening to this book, I wondered if they were the same people. This book argues about topics such as poverty relief, prison reform, exiting foreign wars and helping disadvantaged youth. These are not things the far right is generally associated with. It is fitting that in the book, Koch even laments having spent time and money in partisan politics. 

Koch aligns more with a self-empowering libertarian philosophy and decries top down approaches, whether they come from government or the private sector. The War on Poverty has been a failure. Huge amounts of money have been spent. This has left life a little more pleasant for the poor. However, it has not eradicated poverty. It has created the "Poverty-Industrial complex" Many people are dependent on these programs, both as a source of employment and as a beneficiaries. The programs are based on "smart" people telling others what is best for them. Instead, money would be better spent on things that would most help people to rise out of poverty. This would require substantial input from those in need, rather than the political party in power.

On the other end, corporate welfare has proven to be a huge waste of money that benefits the dinosaur companies. Rather than spend effort innovating and changing, companies seek handouts and beneficial regulations from the government. This makes it more difficult for others to compete. Existing unions and big companies benefit from this arrangement. 

The education institutions are also criticized as being too "one size fits all". Many of the reforms merely make this worse. Rather than individualize, the reforms (such as "No Child Left Behind") seek to standardize education on a much greater scale. School reform with private or charter schools often just window dresses the existing standard paradigm. A better education experience would be based on individual needs and desires. People have a desire to learn what they find valuable. Unfortunately, our education system just feeds everybody the same basic curriculum. 

For social and corporate success, Koch advocates a bottom up approach. Let the ideas come from the people on the ground. Let many of these ideas be tried. Many will fail. That is a good thing. Both individuals and organizations can learn from the failure. Willingness to try and fail will also help find the ideas that will succeed. Everyone might not agree on all points. They still agree on some things. (Frederick Douglass and Abraham Lincoln differed on details of ending slavery, but they both agreed it was bad.) Many people locked up in prisons, or on the dole in inner cities have significant talents that are being squandered.  Everybody has a different set of strengths and talents. The world would be improved if they all had a chance to be used together.

Saturday, October 02, 2021

The Evolution of Everything: How New Ideas Emerge

Atheist Evolutionary Predestined Libertarianism. That pretty much sums up the Ridley's principles. He is advocating the opposite of the "great man" view of history. Everything was destined to happen. Some people may slow progress through their interventions, but can do little to help things along. The best course of action is for government and culture to get out of the way and let things happen. 

Areas that have the most government involvement (such as education and healthcare) tend to stagnate, with cost going up without significant innovation. The background on education is quite interesting. Private education was taking off in a big way in the United States. However, people saw what was going on in Prussia and decided that would be a good model. (The Prussians were upset about the condition of their troops, so they wanted to train them to be high quality conformists ready to fight.) This manner of education continues to serve as our basic model. When asking for funding, the education establishment will bring about the need to teach people basic skills. However, that could be carried out much more effectively for a small fraction of the cost. What public education really provides is indoctrination. The goal is for students to have the appropriate beliefs that the current establishment desires. The education institutions also have a vested interest in protecting their jobs and continue their rent seeking behavior. Instead of keeping the ossified structure in place, we should let it continue to evolve to better provide for students. (Even formal private education is often over-regulated today.)

There are often many bad policies put in place as the elite tries to "help" others like the poor. They assume that they know what other people need and want, so they mandate it, rather than let things evolve. Zoning regulations were put in place to separate living conditions from jobs. Parking requirements, floor area ratios and other regulations were put in place to provide ideal living conditions. Isn't it ironic, they people still flock to live in old parts of cities that did not adhere to those regulations? If we just let things evolve, some might be that way. But others would not. Government gets in the way. We try to guess how things will turn out, but really only slow things down. Children are most influences by their genes and their peers. I guess that gives parents a role in picking a location for their peers. But, most of the future will just "evolve".

Thursday, July 01, 2021

The Fountainhead

I started reading Fountainhead a few decades ago. In the process I fell in love with architecture. However, I never did manage to finish it. Now was the time to finally make it through. It was worth it. The book has a strong reputation among the more right-leaning crowd. There are a few libertarian soliloquies. However, there is plenty from the other sides also. 

Fountainhead focuses on the lives of two architects: Howard Roark and Peter Keating. Roark has strong idealistic principles. He feels that architecture is a special art and that an architect is bound to idealistic principles. He will not sacrifice these principles for any whims of those commissioning his work. Because of this, he is kicked out of architecture school. However, he does have great talent and is able to get some jobs, though his principles continue to cause him trouble. Eventually, he joins with a senior modernist architect (who is now out of favor). They do some limited great work together. Roark goes out on his own and gets some commissions from people who agree with his vision. However, he is often ridiculed. When his firm fails, he is perfectly fine doing manual labor. (Maybe this is what made the book so appealing when working a manual labor job.) 

Keating is a friend of Roark from the school days who goes on the opposite path. He does not have the skills of Roark, yet he is willing to schmooze and follow the rules. He graduates from school. He gets a good job. He rises to heights in the architecture profession. He marries a beautiful woman. Along the way he attempts to attract Roark to his path on numerous times. Roark works for his company, yet is turned away. A few times Roark helps Keating on his designs, essentially designing buildings that Keating takes credit for. Roark is fine with this. Keating, however, is much more challenged by Roark.

Dominique Francon is the woman. She is perhaps the most complex. She falls in love with Roark, the anonymous laborer. They are clandestine lovers while at the same time she is complicit in efforts to ruin Roark's career. He is greatly turned on by him, but can't find any way in which she can have any strength in the relationship. She later married Peter Keating. She is.a prize wife, but they have a passionless relationship (in spite of her giving in to his desires.) She divorces him and then is married to a newspaper magnate. This is a more challenging and fulfilling relationship. However, both of them are admirers of Roark and his talents and idealism.

Ellsworth Toohey is the architecture critic who despises Roark. He  helps bring up other architects, such as Keating, only to brush them aside later. He attempts to speak "for the people", but is really just spattering off his own beliefs. He goes through elaborate schemes to bring him down. He encourages a wealthy man to have Roark design a "temple for humanity", then criticizes the structure, ruining Roark and his firm.

It feels that all the other characters are just there to push Roark in one direction or the other. However, he will just not move. He seems to have a case of high functioning autism. He has great skill. He cares that the buildings are right. He does not really care about people or the praise of men. He would much rather have a building built "right" than have credit for it. He is also drawn towards other artists with artwork that he admires. His architectural ideals sometimes are in line with those of society, but more often they are out of step. He has relationships with other people, but seems to have few tight binds. He is perfectly willing to forgive people for atrocious wrongs without holding any grudge. (He remained close to both people who had married the only woman he was close to.) The one thing that he cannot stand is violation of his art. He destroys a building that had been modified from his plan. 

While the book is often held up as a libertarian magnum opus, it can be easily be adapted by the left. Even somebody like Greta Thunberg has some Roark in her. There is a strong unwavering passion. There is little concern for what others say or do. The work is the joy. Many musicians and other artists are focussing on their art today. They refuse to "sell out" and become a Keating. They would much rather stay true like Roark. If fame comes, so be it. They will take it, but won't let it change them.

Sunday, December 08, 2013

For Us, The Living: A Comedy of Customs

This was Heinlein's first book, yet it was not published until after his death. It is nominally a science fiction book. However, in reality it is a platform for the Heinlein's political beliefs. It starts with a guy driving in the summer of 1938. He gets in a crash and suddenly finds himself rescued in the winter of 2068. The protagonist gets to know his rescuer and his new world. That's about it for the plot.

The new world is a Heinlein libertarian utopia. Europe has been pretty much destroyed by wars and their aftermath. The US has an isolationist policy with a new "economy". (Bankers are evil.) There was a war against south america that killed off most bankers and led to the better government. People can do what they want. The government prints money. People get a regular subsidy and can work whenever they want to. (and not work when they don't want to.) Family relationships and clothing are optional. Public and private life are separated.

The book contains long treatises on the economics and other points of view. This seems like an academic paper that was then transformed into a novel. Alas, there are huge flaws in the "world" he envisions, but it is always nice to dream. Exploring the world in a novel is much more interesting than writing a dry economic paper. Perhaps the best way to criticize it would be to write a novel where a society attempted to implement the Heinlein utopia with disastrous results.

Friday, February 15, 2013

Myths Lies and Downright Stupidity

[June 2009] This book does a convincing job of exposing myths about 'policy issues'. He was also able to make clear fact-based arguments refuting other bits of conventional wisdom, arguing that businesses like regulation and republicans love to increase spending. Hearing a car dealer say that requiring car purchases to be made through car dealers in order to "preserve car dealers" is fairly convincing. Lawyers prohibiting anyone other than a lawyer to fill out forms is also in the similar vein. (Sure there probably are a few people protected from shysters - but in the end, it is protecting the well being of a few.) Arguments against the excesses of malpractice also work well, using a mix of anecdotes and statistics to show that they have gone too far.

When he gets into the scientific realm, however, he is much less convincing. He picks his arguments to make broad 'absolute' conclusions. When discussing global warming, for instance, he refutes the arguments of some scientific studies by citing other scientific studies. Simply choose different studies and the argument can be spun around. In some topics he chooses a single scientific study to bolster a point, while in another he refutes a point as being based only on a single study. And some arguments avoid studies altogether and rely on anecdotes.

In the end, it can best be viewed as a libertarian policy outline. The beliefs are set out, and appropriate arguments are given to bolster those beliefs. There is plenty of content to rile both conservatives and liberals. The delivery is fast paced and entertaining, even if there are holes in the reasoning.

Saturday, November 24, 2012

The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress


The moon is an oppressed penal colony. With the aid of a supercomputer, some residents plan a rebellion. A lot of time is spent discussing the details. Through some chance events, the revolution gets started. Then they attempt to be recognized by earth. Their "recognition" comes in the form of an attack. They defeat the invaders, and launch an attack on earth. After this attack, earth countries recognize the moon's independence as legitimate.

While the plot can be easily explained in a paragraph, the real purpose of this book is for Heinlein to describe his libertarian philosophy. The moon society operates largely without formal laws. The experience as a colony with limited control has lead the residents to act in their best, societal interests. Family structure involves complex, multi-generational families. While there are no formal marriage laws, the structure dictates what can be done. Similarly, other "crimes" are often punished by elimination rather than formal rules.

Heinlein sees government as an entity that usually mandates what had previously been permitted. Instead, he would like for government to create a constitution dictating what the government could not do, rather than what it could do. Its those "do-gooders" that keep trying to inflict their will on others that cause all the problems.

It makes anarchy seem nice and dandy. However, the revolution could only be carried out with the help of a quasi-sentient computer. The computer rigged the elections, "made speeches", launched the missiles, and pretty much did everything else that needed to be done. It seems that what Heinlein is really after is a "computeraucracy". Luckily, Heinlein's computer seems to disapear as soon as the revolution is "won". Philip K. Dick has written similar stories about computers that "control" the life of humans long after the battle is over. Alas, that would have ruined Heinlein's libertarian utopia.