Showing posts with label charity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label charity. Show all posts

Saturday, February 05, 2022

Believe in People: Bottom-Up Solutions for a Top-Down World

I often hear of the Koch brothers mentioned in the context of "radical right wing". When listening to this book, I wondered if they were the same people. This book argues about topics such as poverty relief, prison reform, exiting foreign wars and helping disadvantaged youth. These are not things the far right is generally associated with. It is fitting that in the book, Koch even laments having spent time and money in partisan politics. 

Koch aligns more with a self-empowering libertarian philosophy and decries top down approaches, whether they come from government or the private sector. The War on Poverty has been a failure. Huge amounts of money have been spent. This has left life a little more pleasant for the poor. However, it has not eradicated poverty. It has created the "Poverty-Industrial complex" Many people are dependent on these programs, both as a source of employment and as a beneficiaries. The programs are based on "smart" people telling others what is best for them. Instead, money would be better spent on things that would most help people to rise out of poverty. This would require substantial input from those in need, rather than the political party in power.

On the other end, corporate welfare has proven to be a huge waste of money that benefits the dinosaur companies. Rather than spend effort innovating and changing, companies seek handouts and beneficial regulations from the government. This makes it more difficult for others to compete. Existing unions and big companies benefit from this arrangement. 

The education institutions are also criticized as being too "one size fits all". Many of the reforms merely make this worse. Rather than individualize, the reforms (such as "No Child Left Behind") seek to standardize education on a much greater scale. School reform with private or charter schools often just window dresses the existing standard paradigm. A better education experience would be based on individual needs and desires. People have a desire to learn what they find valuable. Unfortunately, our education system just feeds everybody the same basic curriculum. 

For social and corporate success, Koch advocates a bottom up approach. Let the ideas come from the people on the ground. Let many of these ideas be tried. Many will fail. That is a good thing. Both individuals and organizations can learn from the failure. Willingness to try and fail will also help find the ideas that will succeed. Everyone might not agree on all points. They still agree on some things. (Frederick Douglass and Abraham Lincoln differed on details of ending slavery, but they both agreed it was bad.) Many people locked up in prisons, or on the dole in inner cities have significant talents that are being squandered.  Everybody has a different set of strengths and talents. The world would be improved if they all had a chance to be used together.

Sunday, October 17, 2021

Uncharitable: How Restraints on Nonprofits Undermine Their Potential (Civil Society: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives)

The biggest takeaway from Uncharitable is that accountants make us do stupid things. Ok. There is more than that, but accounting mechanisms do seem to play an outsized role in what is good or bad with charities. Dan Pallotta had a successful company that organized major "active" charitable events, such as AIDS bicycle rides, and multi-day breast cancer walks. Then there was backlash and his company lost his contracts and went belly up. Some of his former employees went on to work directly for the charities to put on events. So, yeah. He has an axe to grind. The charities thought they would get more money by doing it on their own. Alas, they netted much less when they tried. Eventually they did ramp up to similar levels. Would they have been even higher if they kept with him?

The book rambles on for a long time about the Puritan ethic and the history of the separation of for-profit and non-profit distinction. 

The primary argument is that charities need to operate more like business. They should hire the best and compensate them appropriately. They should be willing to look to the long term. They should take risks and be willing to fail. Judging a charity merely on the percentage of funds that "go to the cause" encourages short-term behavior and creative accounting. It also penalizes smaller charities. He does give examples of some of the nonsense this behavior encourages. Having a company donate goods or services rather than donate money makes things look better, but is really just an accounting sleight of hand. 

There is some interesting discussion on advertising. Church goers tend to donate more to secular causes because they hear weekly propaganda on the benefits of charity. Similarly, charities receive large donations after a major catastrophe because of all the "free publicity" of the news. Corporations also spend money to advertise their products. Why shouldn't charities also advertise more? Aren't they providing a better service?

There are a number of good points in the book. There is also an underlying hurt that he felt from his past experiences. A lot of it boils down to what we think of a charity. The government provides favorable tax treatment and in return makes rules. We tend to follow through. While a charity does not need to be a non-profit organization, it is harder to convince people to donate. Higher education is its own separate beast. For profit colleges have been piloried and discredited. Yet colleges have been free to pay coaches millions of dollars - amounts that would not be tolerated at other non-profits. Would it be a problem if coach compensation were limited? Probably not. On the other hand, do we need to pay non-profit executives huge amounts? We could argue that for-profit executive compensation has become excessive. A more moderate non-profit salary could allow somebody to live comfortable at the 95% of income, and still earn a small fraction of a for-profit executive. No need to repeat the mistakes of the private sector. Would it be better to let the private sector executives make the big bucks and donate them to charity?

Other handcuffs of charities do need to be looked into. We should let charities focus more on innovation and long term development. It seems silly to require all donations received after a big event to be dedicated to that event. (Would this just encourage more creative accounting? Much of the work responding to the event was started before the donations flowed - using previous donations.) The difficulty remains in evaluating quality of charitable programs. Numbers are easy.