Showing posts with label Grover Gardner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Grover Gardner. Show all posts

Saturday, July 25, 2026

Absalom, Absalom!

Absalom, Absalom! by William Faulkner

The novel fails like it should be a drama with a great musical score. The novel straddles the civil war, with Thomas Sutpen coming to Mississippi and building up a great plantation. He has strict racial views and disowns a wife and child after he learns that she has some black blood. He desperately wants a true heir. His next son seems good, but he flees after murdering his half-brother with white blood. Another woman births him a daughter. He is upset with this, which eventually leads to the woman's grandfather murdering Sutpen. The runaway heir later returns in tatters and dies in a fire. The dynasty is officially gone. The story is told from the view of people with connections to the Sutpen in the early 1900s. The strict southern beliefs end up leading to a similar downfall for a man. The narrator (now at Harvard in the early 1900s) ends by saying he does not hate the south. The book has great pageantry, though it is difficult to grasp the plot.

Wednesday, August 06, 2025

The Innocents Abroad: Or, The New Pilgrim’s Progress

The Innocents Abroad: Or, The New Pilgrim’s Progress by Mark Twain

Mark Twain went on a trip with a group of Americans to visit the Holy Land and many places in between. Twain's wit and humour make for one of the better travel stories. The trip and the actions of everyone involved are more important than the actual site. The profiteering of the locals is critisized outright, while the naive behavior of Americans gets criticized in passing. As an example, in Paris, the tour guide goes through great efforts to take them to so many different stores that it becomes too late to visit the museum they had asked to visit. The Americans naively believe they just needed to better instruct what they wanted to do. The Americans end up calling all guides by the same name.

When they finally get to the Holy Land, Twain is let down by the small scale of things. It is a small area and extremely impoverished. It was much less grand than he expected. It was difficult to comprehend a deity walking among the people.

Innocentes is an appropriate title. These people seem very innocent and naive. This adds to the humor as they explore historical parts of the world in a relatively clueless way. 

Thursday, April 17, 2025

2666

2666 by Roberto Bolaño translated Natasha Wimmer

This is a long book that the author at one time envisioned publishing as multiple books. He died before it was finished and his heirs decided to publish it as one thing. The various sections of the book tell their own stories that are somewhat related together. There are sections discussing the life and romantic experiences of an author. One section goes back to World War II and talks about experiences in Nazi controlled areas and the experiences complying with Nazi policies and "taking care of" Jewish populations. A significant section of the book covers crime in a Mexican town. This starts with the experience of a African American journalist that is sent to cover a boxing match and then gets interested in the the cases. Then there is a section about the murders. There is a criminal that goes crazy in churches. Later there are women that are mysteriously killed. Most have few external connections. Their bodies are often discovered long after their deaths. Eventually an American detective comes in to help resolve the crimes.

I was most interested in the middle section of the novel. Scott Brick always does a great job narrating. Parts at the start and end were not quite as appealing.

Saturday, March 01, 2025

Life on the Mississippi

Life on the Mississippi by Mark Twain

Mark Twain's writing is fresh and witty, even a century and half later. This is a memoir by Twain that focuses on his experiences on the Mississippi. Boats going between Cairo and New Orleans were a primary means of mobility in the pre-railroad era. They were so dominate, that a union of pilots could extract extremely high wages and salaries. This all came to an end when railroads and barges started plying the waters. 

He provides many insights of the river towns of the day. Near the end, he explores the "upper Mississippi" above St. Louis. These cities were growing quickly, from nothing to tens of thousands people. Great sunrises can be seen from cities like Muscatine. Railroad bridges now cross in multiple places. It is a study in technology and growth.

Twain includes historical background and personal experiences as well as many insights and observations. This is a great source of historical information as well as an entertaining read.


Friday, July 19, 2024

The Story of Philosophy: The Lives and Opinions of the Greater Philosophers

The Story of Philosophy: The Lives and Opinions of the Greater Philosophers by Will Durant

This book explores different philosophers and their philosophies, starting with the Greeks and going on to "contemporary" philosophers from the time of the writing (a century ago.) There is analysis of the Greeks and how our interpretation of the Greeks has differed. The modern philosophers come into play. Nietzsche gets a lot of coverage. For contemporary philosophers there is exploration of "new world" and "old world". An interesting quote about the Spanish is that one say them as "Catholic" but no longer Christian. The culture remained even if religion had faded. It is an interesting exploration of philosophy with plenty of opinion. 

Sunday, May 19, 2024

Who?

 Who? by Algis Budrys

Lucas Martino is a key scientist for The Allied National Government. An explosion happens when his doing his work and the Soviet International Block helps restore his health before restoring him. Many parts of his body are artificial. The allies are unsure if he is the "real person" or a spy. He seems to check all the boxes, but the allies are not sure. Eventually, they decide to dismiss him from his work leaving him to live a different life. It turns out that though the Soviets thought to replace him as a spy, they didn't. However, they did succeed in setting back the scientific work while still letting the many live.

Tuesday, November 02, 2021

We

We is a futuristic dystopian novel. A totalitarian state controls everything. Some people engage in clandestine activites (like talk of a soul). There is also a group outside the city that run around without uniforms. They are plotting rebellion. There is also talk of math, with integral and infinity playing a role in the discussion. The grand plans end up failing.

This felt very much like Ayn Rand's Anthem. In both cases, the collective dominates, and the individual is just a number. Things like mating are strictly programmed by the state. However, in We, the society has become technologically advanced, while in Anthem it was not. They both left Russia and had obvious negative feelings towards their homeland.

Thursday, December 03, 2020

The Democracy Project: A History, a Crisis, a Movement

David Graeber, The author of The Democracy Project was one of the key players in the early 2010's Occupy movement. He is an academic, self-proclaimed anarchist and the originator of "the 99%". The book is part history of the Occupy movement and part manual for running an anarchic organization.

He describes the "1%" as the ruling class of the United States. These are the people that are in political and corporate power. They are also those with lots of money that can make donations to political campaigns. While "legal", these contributions are viewed as a form of bribery. The institutions of the state (such as police, laws, courts, etc.) are set up to provide benefit to the 1%. Foreclosures are an example of the apparatus of the state being used to support the 1% against "the 99%". The current system of laws and regulations is so vast that it is impossible to enforce everything. The result is a selective enforcement. The protestors were hit with citations for crimes that were rarely charged. There is almost always "something" illegal that is being performed by somebody. It is up to those in authority to pick and choose what is enforced. This allows for fully "legal" discrimination on those that are out of favor. This also extends out of the state to unions and other organizations. (A bus-drivers union can cause a massive slow down simply by "working to the rule".)

The occupy movement did not have a leadership structure and used consensus to make decisions. Consensus ensures that everybody has a voice and nobody is forced to go along with something they do not believe in. Alas, it does not scale. He does give examples of reducing consensus decisions to those that are important to the body as a whole. (Universal agreement is not needed for designing a logo.) A consensus society would be an ideal. However, implementing it would be close to impossible. Some of the pre-Columbian societies in the Americas may have had the anarchic structure. However, they were also easily destroyed by the hierarchical Europeans.

The author advocates "real" democracy. He criticizes voting as just a means to promulgate the leadership by the elite. The masses are given a small choice between a few elites as a means of keeping them subjugated. There is rarely a choice between vastly different systems. The left can't understand how working class voters chose Republicans, seemingly against their own self interest. However, the voters realize that the Democrats are merely throwing them a few bones. There is little significant difference between the two parties. The constitution specifically did not have direct democracy, but merely a system of elected officials.

Full democracy is common in protest movements, but has rarely succeeded on a large scale. Pirate crews would often implement a democratic structure - after they had mutinied against their original ship leadership. Small communes have also had varying degrees of success with full democratic organization. On a large scale, there are just too many people and too many decisions to maintain direct democracy. These problems eventually led to the downfall of the occupy movement. 

Sunday, July 05, 2020

Wealth and Poverty: A New Edition for the Twenty-First Century

Wealth and Poverty is a book that would not be popular with modern racial activists (like Black Life Matters.) The author praises capitalists as the most important people in creating value and prosperity. They are not driven by greed, but are powered by information. They take risks and know to maximize value of their capital. Even if they have capital taken from them, they are likely to create new capital (while the taken capital will have limited value.)
Gilder believes that broken families and welfare policy are the primary policies that keep the poor down. He thinks some level of subsistence aid and benefits are valuable. (He sees this is a step above China where those that don't work don't eat.) However, the current scheme discourages people from working. It is actually quite demeaning because it assumes that taking away benefits when people start working will not discourage work. The welfare structure discourages nuclear family. However, the nuclear family is one of the key "innovations" that has allowed great economic growth. In addition to family, faith is an important component in getting out of poverty. Welfare makes it less likely that the families will move out of poverty. It also emasculates the working man, and makes it more likely that families will struggle from broken homes. Welfare recipients are also encouraged to work "under the table" so that they do not lose their benefits. Government has been quick to integrate new immigrants into the welfare culture, rather than let them innovate and grow.
On the other end, large corporations are also problematic. They are often efficient at producing some well established good. However, they are bureaucratic and slow to innovate. They are more likely to seek out benefits. Big businesses are eager to seek regulations that will make it more difficult for others to compete. Big corporations are also apt at demanding bailouts when the markets turn against them. Chrysler is an interesting case in point. They received a huge government bailout in part to "keep them American". Alas, today, they are no under their second foreign owner.
A key point of the analysis is that the same "facts" can tell very different stories depending on how they are analyzed. There are always more variables that can be added to analysis to tell different stories. Some "tricks" include using dynamic vs static data. ("The lowest 20% of earners has seen no earnings increase" is often looking at the static group. However, if we look at the participants, we may find that Jeff Bezos was once in the lowest quartile and now is a multi-billionare. Meanwhile, a high school student has now taken his place in the "lowest 20%") Accounting can also change the analysis. Our "progressive" tax structure becomes extremely regressive when transfer payments are included. A marginal dollar of earning can cause the loss of medicaid and welfare benefits. Working an "above the board" job could result in a loss of income. For health benefits it could be much worse. Medicaid covers medical expenses without cost. However, a purchased health plan will often have deductibles and copays, making the costs higher.
His argument as a whole is very sound. However, there are a few areas where he misses the mark. For transportation, he objects to government takeover of railroads. However, he misses the fact that this was necessitated by the government subsidization of other means of transit (such as highways, parking and airports.) The public sector spent heavily to favor cars, both in direct construction costs (roads) and in regulations (parking requirements). In many cases the railroads subsidies were an extension of this in a hope to retain existing infrastructure after roads and parking reached capacity. Another issues is with the environment. This is a tricky one. Government regulation has often proved problematic in this area. There are huge amounts of regulation that attempt to protect the environment. However, they are excessively complex and prone to abuse. Environmental Impact requirements can be used as an excuse to stop valid economic activity. Meanwhile, environmentally destructive activity can continue to hum along. This is a challenging area. There needs to be a way to internalize the shared environmental costs, yet we also need to allow for innovative activity.
Some of the fixes Gilder proposes would make a lot of sense, but may be difficult to implement. It is interesting that he has given examples of left-wing governments (in Canada and New Zealand) that have implemented more supply side policies. Right wing governments often get bogged down in talk of "balanced budgets". In the US, the Republicans and Democrats are both beholden to their special interests and favored parts of the bureaucracy. The suggestion to eliminate means-testing in welfare benefits could be very expensive, but very beneficial to the economy. Today there is a perverse incentive to reduce income in order to receive benefits. Similarly, the tax system encourages various shelters to avoid taxation. It would be better if the government would just back off. Alas, there are huge bureaucracies created around these programs that encourage their propagation.

Tuesday, June 18, 2019

Wisdom of Crowds

As long as people are independently making decisions, the average results of a group of people are likely to be better than the results of any one person. Each person brings their own little bit of knowledge that helps get the answer closer to what it should be. However, if people share knowledge, before deciding, they are likely to negatively impact their decision making. The knowledge can taint an individual decision. This can also lead to people engaging in groupthink. Sometimes the best behavior is to follow the crowd that has wisely decided. (If everyone is carrying umbrellas, it may be wise to carry one also.) However, if this gets carried too far out, their may not be anybody making the decision, and we thus get a random herd.
Decision making can be improved by having all viewpoints aired before engaging in deliberation. The more diverse the group and the more willing they are to share differing opinions, the better the outcome is likely to be.

Sunday, September 09, 2018

Internal Time: Chronotypes, Social Jet Lag, and Why You're So Tired

Internal Time divides the discussion of time into 24 chapters. It presents a number of fictional and semi-factual stories of people in various "odd time" situations as it discusses how time impacts us in our lives. The human clock is almost set to 24 hours. However, there are slight differences, and the body relies on external queues (sunrise) to guide us on the daily schedule. Teenagers tend to arise later, and gradually arise earlier each year until late middle age. (Women actually start this schedule a little ahead of men.) Birds use an internal clock in order to guide their long migrations. Some people may have conditions that cause them to wake up much earlier than normal. Without sensory perceptions, it can be hard to accurately keep track of time.
Time is quite an interesting phenomenon. Mammals may have even evolved to dominate the night (since the air, sea and land were already taken.) Being warm blooded allowed them to be active when other cold blooded animals lacked energy. Later, mammals went back to the day time. However, man was still created innovations like houses and light to continue to dominate the night.

Friday, July 21, 2017

The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: A History of Nazi Germany

William Shirer was a journalist who lived in Germany during the rise of Hitler. The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich covers the life of Hitler and his rise and eventual fall from power. It is extremely verbose, and spends a lot of time covering the early stages of the third Reich (the time when the author was present in Germany.) He inserts plenty of his own opinion in the work. The author seems to have an extremely negative few of Hitler, with an underlying message that he only came to power because of his Stormtrooper thugs. However, that does seem a bit too simplistic. (Were these thugs requiring everyone to buy Mein Kaumpf?) He is quick to demean all aspects of national socialism. (The Nazi "arts" were constantly demeaned.) The rise felt like it was excessively colored by the knowledge of the impending fall.

The "fall" part is more rushed. Much of the space is devoted to the cruelty of the nazi regime. The "science experiments" may have had some intention of finding ways to help German troops, but they were primarily just torture and executions. The torture and extermination of the Jews had no excuse other then that the German's thought they were the source of problems. Even slavs were treated as inferior, with education of these "brutes" seen as something bad.
The book has a strong journalistic feel. It delves into the sensationalist and the strong personality. The historical actions are covered, but not in as great detail as the characters. Hitler's petty attacks and grudges are presented as a reason for Germany's defeat. If he would not have devoted effort to quash Yugoslavia, the Soviet attack could have been carried out earlier, leading to a more likely German victory. If he wouldn't have pandered to his "alies" (or stabbed them in the back) he could have kept his small empire without further conflict. The many attempts to assassinate Hitler are also given plenty of coverage. What would have happened if they had succeeded?

Saturday, April 01, 2017

Conscious Capitalism

Conscious Capitalism is part business book, part history of Whole Foods and part political philosophy. The book is written in the voice of the founder and former CEO of whole foods, John Mackey. He has experienced both the the Austin-style socialism as well as free market capitalism. He has grown to be not too fond of socialism, and instead views capitalism as the force that can provide the greatest benefit for mankind. However, modern capitalism has often strayed from its positive roots and evolved to be more crony-capitalism. Many of the complaints from the left can be better addressed by a conscious form of capitalism than by socialism.

Conscious Capitalism can not be a whitewashing of a "mainstream" capitalism. It requires different values and commitments to value all the stakeholders. Suppliers, customers, employees and the community all have a say. When everyone feels valued they work better together and can achieve better results than can be achieved with command and control. Because conscious companies work together with their employees there is no need for unions. (Mackey gave an example of store in Madison that unionized. The union made many promises. Due to rules, the company was unable to make promises or implement changes on its own. However, at the non-unionized stores, the company was able to increase benefits, leaving the Madison store behind. They eventually voted to remove the union.) Advertising is also minimized. Customers can relate to the company and share their positive experiences. This word-of-mouth advertising is stronger and less costly.

Conscious companies still value profits. However, they are a means to delighting stakeholders rather than an end goal. When times are tough conscious companies have a chance to show their true commitment to stakeholders can be shown. All parties need to work together to make the appropriate stakeholders. They all have a say in things, rather than having something dictated from above. If done well, it can pa significant dividends over the long run.

The book describes many companies (such as Southwest Airlines, REI, Costco, Trader Joe's and Tata Group) that act as conscious companies. An empirical study also showed they significantly outperformed the stock market. (However, is this really causation? Or is it that high-performing companies chose to be more conscious?) It takes work to be a conscious company. Everyone can benefit, however, people may not want to make the change. The sacrifice can be greatest for those on top who will no longer be able to enjoy some of the "perks" of the position. It also may appear to be doing poorly in the short run. The past reputation and inertia may take a while to overcome. It also does not produce the instant results that Wall Street likes to see. In the long run, however, it encapsulates many of the important principles of good leadership and society. It is one of the ways that business can save itself from the anti-business climate permeating society.

Monday, December 19, 2016

Debt: The First 5,000 Years

The history of "debt" predates the introduction of money. Even today, people will often say they are "indebted" to you due to a favor or other action performed. In Debt, David Graeber explores the history of debt and the origin of money. He presents a view different than the commonly described story. He wasn't able to find viable cases of money rises out of the "barter economy." Instead, he found it rising more out of the "human" economy. People would become indebted to others due to an accident, murder or taking of a spouse. The monetary instruments would come about as a means to satisfy these debts (and help but an end to the cycle of endless retribution.)

The evolution of standardized currency allowed greater exchanges with unknown people. (Now the trust was placed in the type of currency rather than the individual person.) Standardization also better facilitated warfare and plunder.

Slavery was also tied to debt and money. Slavery initially arose in a somewhat positive context. Rather than kill an enemy, they could be enslaved for a time period. Slaves could live relatively normal lives and in some cultures eventually obtain freedom. Slavery became common in societies that undertook large scale projects. Eventually, it fell out of favor in Europe of the middle ages. However, with the plantation demands of the new world, there was a need for increased labor. Slavery had to be "forced" back upon a society that had given up on it. To do this, a racist story had to be introduced to portray the slaves as less than human. As long as people bought this tale, slavery could exist. However, as people realized they had been duped (and the need for slave labor decreased), slavery fell out of favor. It was eventually abolished, yet we are still living the legacy of the marginalization of a group of people and the culture that grew out of it.

Wage labor also grew out of the needs of large scale industry. It bares many similarities to the slave system. The key difference is that people are free to move around and "move up." However, in practice, most people remain wage laborers for their lives. They may move from job to job, yet these jobs tend to be very similar to each other. They are required to do work to pay off their many debts (houses, credit cards, etc.) The many transactions performed also tend to be done in a more anonymous fashion. People rarely communicate directly with an individual holding their debt or producing their product. Debt has become a unifying instrument of an anonymous society.

Tuesday, August 19, 2014

Oil!

Why do I always seem to get Upton Sinclair and Sinclair Lewis confused? Similar names with an overlapping time period will do that.

In the Jungle, Upton Sinclair attempted to write a novel advocating for workers' rights. Instead, he ended up alarming everyone to the dangers of poor food safety. In Oil! he tries again. Again, his story manages to fail in its original goal, while succeeding in other levels.

I found myself sympathizing with the corrupt father. He saw business as a means unto itself. What was best for his business was best for everyone. Bribes were an important part of getting things properly done. They just a small expense that helped to extract maximum value. Bad things may happen, but you must keep going. On the surface the father seems horrid. However, you can't help but be attached to him. He really wanted the best for everyone. He would unite with the oil companies in keeping the wages down, but support the oil workers with housing. Maybe these corrupt businessmen really do have our interest at heart.

The workers and the communists are less desirable. These people seem to be in it for themselves. The communists, especially, seem to be proto-hippies, overly idealistic, but waffling and even being hypocritical in carrying things out. They try to be physically peaceful while at the same time riling everyone up. The main character wants to support the workers and thinks the communists and socialists have good ways of doing it. However, he also enjoys some of the trappings of the well-to-do lifestyle. They also can't decide what to do with traditional morals. Are they imposed or beneficial? Will it detract from the movement.

There is also an ultra hypocritical evangelical preacher, a gold digging wife and a stolen inheritance thrown in for good measure.

It is fascinating to read this from the time period in which it was written. You could place many of those discussions in the 1960s or the 2010s and they would come out the same. When this book was written, the cold war was far in the future. The Great Depression and World War II were also years away. Yet many of the conversations and activities could have easily taken place in 1969 or 2013. Do all generations go through the same phases?

Surprisingly, Oil plays very little role in the story. Sure, it is the background and the source of the family's money. (Which alas, doesn't make it past the death of the father.) We do get pits of how it influences some of the development patterns, especially in California, but it plays a minor role in this story of life in the roaring 20s.

Monday, January 13, 2014

Energized


Energized is a Russia-American spy thriller set in a near-future science fiction universe. The Arab's have nuke their oil fields wrecking havoc on energy supplies. The world is trying rapidly to produce alternative energy sources, however, it is slow moving. Russia with its oil supplies has emerged the big winner. Meanwhile a space object slipped out of its orbit and started coming towards earth. Through some manipulation this was made to be a second moon. It provided an ideal base for harvesting the sun's energy and beaming it back to earth. This could be a solution to the energy needs of the planet. However, there are environmental concerns. These come to a head when some "terrorists" manage to gain control and start beaming down energy on alternate power sources to destroy them. Our protaganist just happened to be on a mission there at the time and is able to help defeat the bad guys with the help of his new girlfriend and the guy who secretly sent the moon there in the first place. The restore everything, make the world safe and make sure the Russian bad guy is zapped by his own medicine. Now more energy will be available and people will be free to continue their conspicuous consumption. (As an aside, it is mentioned that if we just reduced some of the excess consumption, none of this would be needed.)

It is a fairly conventional thriller plot wrapped in a cautionary tale of the environment. It comes down squarely on the side of rapid new technology as the solution for energy problems. However, it does caution against over-dependence on a single source of power - especially when it is controlled by less-than-desirable entities.