Showing posts with label agriculture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label agriculture. Show all posts

Friday, October 18, 2024

Triumph of Seeds

The Triumph of Seeds: How Grains, Nuts, Kernels, Pulses & Pips Conquered the Plant Kingdom and Shaped Human History by Thor Hanson

Seeds are key to survival and propagation of life, yet they are not well understood. Seeds are "living", but capable of long periods of dormancy. Seeds have successfully sprouted after hundreds or even thousands of years. They often have internal mechanisms to come out when the time is right. They may need just the right moisture or sunlight or other factors. Some need fire to kill off the competition before they sprout.

Seeds are also adapted to their environment. A rainforest seed may need to sprout as soon as possible to outgrow the competition. Other seeds may needs adopt mechanisms to be spread further. Dandelion seeds float. Many seeds are attractive to animals. Some travel through animal digestive systems. Nuts are just hard enough to extract. Animals will carry them away to other locations to eat. Some of these seeds will not be consumed and will be the source of new plants. 

Seed banks store seeds for future use. We have highly protected climate controlled banks set up in various parts of the world. The soil also holds natural seed banks. Soil often holds many seeds waiting for the right time to come out. With diverse crops, many farms previously had a hidden "bank" of many seeds. These would often be traded with others. Today with industrial monoculture, the fortified seed banks often play the role of banking, with seed traders occupying a niche.

Sunday, July 28, 2024

Silent Spring

Silent Spring by  Rachel Carson

DDT and other pesticides are really bad. They hurt people and animals. Broad chemical pest controls may cause a short term fix, but typically result in a long term harm. We should instead focus on narrowly focussed, less toxic means of reducing pests. Silent Spring has plenty of examples, and is fairly well written. It was an influential book that helped lead to the reduction in DDT use. Alas, the lesson learned was narrow, and we we continue to use different broad-based chemical pest controls with various negative impacts.

Thursday, April 11, 2024

The Wizard and the Prophet: Two Remarkable Scientists and Their Dueling Visions to Shape Tomorrow's World

The Wizard and the Prophet: Two Remarkable Scientists and Their Dueling Visions to Shape Tomorrow's World by Charles C. Mann

Norman Borlaug and William Vogt had very different responses to the question of human population growth. Borlaug launched the green revolution. He found ways to increase the food production capacity. He helped breed high-yielding crops. By applying the proper fertilizer and water with the right breed of crop, farmers can produce much greater yields on smaller land. Vogt looked at the negativity of growth and encouraged reductions in the human footprint.

Borlaug won the Nobel prize. However, his achievements are now being reassessed. While it has helped increase yields, there have also been negative results, ranging from environmental degradation to unemployment and obesity.

Now climate change is a big concern. However, we continue to have wizards looking at ways we can continue to consume as before while limiting our carbon footprint. Maybe now is the time to re-think consumption and look at how we can get by with less.

Wednesday, April 10, 2024

Milk Money: Cash, Cows, and the Death of theAmerican Dairy Farm

Milk Money: Cash, Cows, and the Death of the American Dairy Farm by Kirk Kardashian

American dairy farmers do not have it well today. The work is difficult, and the earnings are small and erratic. this book is an exposé of the underbelly of the dairy industry, while being sympathetic to the small family dairy farmer.

Dairy really took off in the northern climates of Europe. Farm animals had been milked in warmer climates. However, the milk was typically consumed in a processed fashion (such as yogurt.) In the north, the growing season was shorter and milk would be a better source of food. People also had genetic adaptations to be able to consume dairy into adulthood. This allowed more consumption of fresh milk. (It would be interesting to see how this came about. Did those with the mutation travel to the north? Or did those in the north with the mutation out-survive others?)

Dairy finances are extremely convoluted. There have been various price support and subsidy schemes in place. At one time, the government promised to buy all excess milk, leading to large storage of cheese and nonfat dry milk. There have been various export schemes. However, American milk is expensive and at is a challenge to compete internationally. Milk is a commodity, and farmers are paid by the hundredweight based on market prices. These are set by a survey, yet often just end up being the low price from the commodity exchange. 

Farmers often sell their milk to processors. They must pay to have the milk hauled away. they must pay for marketing. There are a multitude of items that end up being deducted from what they receive. Even when the are members of cooperatives, there may be factors working against their interest.

Consolidation has happened in the dairy industry. Giants, such as Dean have gobbled up many of the processors and squeezed the producers. Farmers have moved to huge CAFO operations. The health of the cow and the quality of milk are not nearly as important as the quantity produced. There are significant fixed costs involved. It is difficult to reduce production, thus there is a constant pressure to produce more. The giant producer operations can better manage economies of scale. However, they depend on labor - which is often from Mexico and central America. The environmental impact of these giant operations also tends to be much worse.

The book concludes with the "future" of dairy farming. A small scale distributor that focuses on high-quality milk. The milk is not organic, but adheres to higher quality standards. Farmers can be paid more as they focus on brand rather than commodity. This does seem like a nice solution. However, I can only see this being a niche market. Maybe that is what is left for family farmers, while the big guys can focus on the commodity market. The book is an interesting look into the economics of milk. It tries from some personalization, but doesn't succeed as well as some other similar books.

Tuesday, November 22, 2022

What Your Food Ate: How to Heal Our Land and Reclaim Our Health

Reducing food down to carbs, fats and protein misses out on a lot of the key nutritional value. There are many micronutrients that have value that we have yet to understand. Even isolating these misses out on the benefits of the interrelation between various compounds. People have had centuries to select food for nutritional value. 

We have spent a few decades tearing food apart and attempting to provide similar benefit. Alas, we have not done a good job. Taste has previously been a key way to identify food our bodies need. However, as scientists have been able to isolate key macronutrients, they were left with bland food. No problem, they added plenty of flavors to help fool us into liking the "fake" food. Even "natural" food suffers from the same problems. Agriculture has engineered crops for yield rather than taste or nutrition. Fields are covered with fertilizer that makes plants grow fast. They have little time for defenses, thus they are covered with pesticides. This kills off the pest predators also, requiring more pesticides. 

Meat has suffered from similar problems. Livestock are fed grains that are cheap rather than nutritious. This "food" needs to be flavored to get the animals to appropriate consume it. The animals quickly put on weight, but the nutritional value and taste of the meat is lacking. (Argentine grass-fed beef tasted so much better than the feed-lot American beef.) There are also the externalities. Animal waste is great fertilizer on farms, but hazardous waste on a feedlot.

The explores the decline in nutrition in modern food with a goal towards advocating no-till "natural" agricultural processes. Many of today's crops don't work as well in organic, no-till farming because they have been bred specifically for high-fertilizer, conventional farming. Breeding for taste and more natural conditions can produce more nutritious, better tasting produce with yields almost as high as bland conventional ones. We are only beginning to better understand the nutritional benefits. (Nutritional studies remain hard because there are so many different people and different interrelated nutrients.) 


Wednesday, March 10, 2021

Stuffed and Starved: The Hidden Battle for the World Food System - Revised and Updated

Stuffed and Starved is foremost an activist book that seeks to improve the condition of the participants in the global food chain. The food chain has a large number of producers and large number of consumers. However, the bottleneck is the small number of big companies in the middle. Food processing and food retailing are dominated by a few very large companies. Often most of the money spent on food goes to these middlemen. These companies have also helped to encourage monoculture in the name of efficiency.

The author spends a significant amount of time detailing the suicide epidemic among farmers. They are stuck in a spiral of debt to increase yield. This can be followed by a quest for even more production even as prices decline. He also covers small scale "communes" that seek to have more control of the system itself. He advocates a food system where there is more local production and more of the money goes back to the farmers. However, he does give acknowledgement to the challenges. Many of the poorest consumers are living in food desserts where there are few options for quality food. What remains is usually the most shelf-stable, calorie-dense junk food. They would like to have more food options.

Globalization has also played a role in the food industry. After World War II, the United States fed much of the world. The country provided "food aid" dominated by the primary agricultural products (soybeans, corn and wheat.) This encouraged these people to adopt the cheap American staples (such as bread) over local foods. As food aid dropped, there was still demand for the American foods. In Mexico, the US won on price. The subsidized factory-farmed corn was much cheaper to produce than the small scale corn production in Mexico. This hurt the local farmers, even while the cost of tortillas did not significantly fall for most consumers. 

Agriculture giants also provide seed, fertilizer and pesticides. Genetically engineered crops have built in resistance to pesticides or pests. However, they are also costly and must be purchased yearly. The companies encourage the use of their products rather than focusing on soil fertility. This may provide short term gains, but also creates a dependence with some long-term negative impacts.

Farm workers are also some of the lowest paid workers. Most of the major fruit and vegetable crops in the US are picked by low wage migrant workers. However, the crops go through multiple layers of middlemen before they make it to consumers. More direct farm to consumer produce can help, but it is challenging. The author proposes activism and high wages for all. But will it scale? Are people ready to pay more for a more diverse, yet limited supply of food?

Sunday, August 30, 2020

The Way of Ignorance: And Other Essays

Wendell Berry provides insight into issues facing America from the perspective of an intellectual that is deeply connected to the land. The land is not something that is to be left in a "pristine" state to be admired. It is part of a larger ecosystem in which we live. Man must work with the land to provide sustenance. Sustainability is important on a global scale. 

Modern culture has sought to remove the intimate connection people have with the land. Rather than "husbandry", there is now "science". This implies that scientific control as we act on the land, rather than working with the land. This has resulted in massive increases in short term land productivity at the expense of long term sustainability. Science uncovers ways to mechanize and fertilize to increase productivity. Then science must work to find ways to fix the consequences that this damage has caused. These experiments are done on such a massive scale that the consequences are difficult to address.

Today we often have individual groups that attempt to address small aspects of the land degradation problem. Unfortunately, they are often narrowly focused and end up competing with each other. Some groups want pristine wilderness for recreation. Others want land to be used for cattle grazing. They end up fighting for chunks of the land for their purpose. A better solution would be to work together, keeping all the land open for both. If done right, the grazing can help restore and grow the land to make it a better experience for recreating. (Ironically, our national parks are often anything but pristine areas. They are often "protected", preventing some of the natural destruction and renewal from taking place.

Both the "center" and the periphery have their place in our society. We often see one pitted against the other, especially in our red vs. blue political dichotomy. However, it would be better to have "community" against absentee corporatism. The fast food chain on the freeway is just a blip on a corporate accounting book, while the local businesses in town are integrated in the community. The real effort should be to build up the local community with local resources, rather than to fight to see which foreign "savior" can fly in and provide local jobs in return for sucking up resources.

Religion and local knowledge also play important roles in our society. Individual farmers know their local land and have the generational experience to know how to best manage it for good. Religion can be a unifying force as well as provide a groundwork for positively relating towards other. (In one essay, Berry explores how he has worked through his understanding of Christianity.) Science, mechanism and technology can provide some benefit. However, we must look at the long term picture. We need to continue to work to increase our local connections to other people and the land.

Thursday, November 21, 2019

The Worst Hard Time: The Untold Story of Those Who Survived the Great American Dust Bowl

The dust bowl is scary in that it happened in relatively recent history and we have learned very little from it. The southern plains of the US were some of the last areas settled. The region was though of as the great American desert, and not very suitable for residents or agriculture. However, it was the last "open land" and was finally gobbled up in the early 20th century. Alas, a combination of factors led to rapid environmental destruction. A boom in grain prices and a adequate precipitation led to farmers plowing everything in site. The excess grain helped, coupled with the onset of the great depression caused prices to tumble. The immediate response was to plow even more land, further depressing prices. With prices so low, many farmers abandoned their fields altogether. And then a drought struck. The land that had once been covered with native grasses had been denuded and just blew away, causing the massive dust storms that spread dust across the country. Meanwhile, the economy was stuck with low grain prices and excess grain nobody wanted to buy. We still see similar aspects repeat. Dotcom and housing bubbles followed a similar economic trap. There is still great tendency to "outsmart" the environment.
The book spends much of the time covering Dalhart, Texas and Boise City, Oklahoma, two cities in the panhandles of their states. Boise City was started as a fraud, falsely advertised by prospectors that didn't even have title to the land. They went to jail, but the city grew. Dalhart sprouted up close to the huge XIT cattle ranch.
Some of the environmental conditions are hard to fathom. The dust was omnipresent, causing dust pneumonia. The big dust storms would bury houses and completely block vision. Grasshopper swarms would later come through and eat everything, even wooden handles of farm implements. There were also the extremes of heat and cold (but those were more "normal"). There was a reason it was called no-man's land. It was amazing how quickly people were able to cause so much damage.
The people living there prided themselves with being self-reliant. However, once things got bad, they were eagerly begging the government to help them get themselves out of the mess. A combination of over-plowing and under planting caused a huge ecological catastrophe that could not be easily repaired individually. (In somewhat ironic twist, when President Roosevelt visited Amarillo, it was pouring down rain.)
The book follows a few people that lived in the area, including the founder of the "last man" club, who ended up decamping to a job in another town. Some others toughed it out longer, but most ended up with pretty much nothing at the end.

Wednesday, February 06, 2019

Dirt: The Erosion of Civilizations

The top layer of "dirt" is what helps our civilizations survive. Many great empires have died after a thousand years due in part to their destruction of this topsoil. Darwin dedicated his final career work to the exploration of topsoil production and the important role that worms played in producing more soil. The early book spends a great deal of time discussing different civilizations and the impact they had on the topsoil. Soil degradation is viewed as a significant reason for the rise and fall of empires. As populations grow, irrigation and other large scale works are needed to help support overfarmed soils. This leads to creation of government structures. Further growth leads to farming of marginal lands and erosion. Vast empires are needed to provide food for the urban areas. Eventually, the degradation puts the society on the edge, and a small climatic change or weather anomaly can push the society over the edge. "Empire" food production can lead to events like the Irish Potato famine. Many people in Ireland starved due to the potato crop failure. Meanwhile, cattle were being exported from Ireland to England.
The author does a great job of making his point. He uses simple math to show that intensive agriculture results in a rate of soil erosion that limits most civilizations to primary lifespan of about 1000 years. Some can last longer if they are blessed with renewable soil (like the Nile River), or can extend their farming reach. However, without care to the soil, they will fall. Soil is a tricky resource because the benefits of conservation often don't occur until the following generation. It is very hard to get political buy in for the short term sacrifices needed for long term gain.
While the ideas in the book are good, the writing is not. The chapters are organized by topic, but they ramble on, jumping around from example to example somewhat haphazardly. The point could be made in a book a fraction of the size. The ideas are strong enough to encourage making it through the book in spite of the poor organization.

Sunday, November 18, 2018

Growing a Revolution: Bringing Our Soil Back to Life

In Growing a Revolution David R. Montgomery advocates farming practices that center upon building healthy soil. Conventional agriculture depletes soil of nutrients and gradually leads to an erosion of topsoil. Fertilizer attempts to restore some of the critical nutrients. However, it does not restore the important micro organisms that help make healthy soil. Also, a good portion of the fertilizer runs off, contaminating water supplies. In addition, the tendency to plant the same crops over and over makes them more subject to pests, requiring more pesticides, leading to resistant pests and more pesticide use.
He advocates for "no till farming" with crop rotations. Rather than plow the ground, the previous crops are used for mulch. New crops (of a different variety) are planted in the ground. The organic matter decays and improves the health of the soil. The rotation and planting of cover crops helps improve the health of the soil and make it more resistant to pests. This healthier soil is also much better at holding water than plowed soil. No till farming can be either organic or conventional. In general, it may more closely resemble organic farming because of less dependence on pesticides and fertilizer. However, the practice can be done with either conventional or organic approaches. (Pest control with conventional would still be an acceptable if needed.) An initial shift to no-till farming may see a drop in productivity. However, as the soil health builds up, productivity tends to be similar to conventional farming. However, the input costs of no-till farming practices are much less. Thus, even when productivity is lower, the no-till farms are still much more profitable.
The main problem with no-till farming is that there is not a business interest behind it. It results in lower demand for big agrichemicals. Perhaps what they need to do is get big farm implement companies behind it. There has to be a good deal of money behind "no-till" tractor equipment. Perhaps seed companies could also get behind selling more seeds. (Though the author does discuss a breeder who is working on perennial grains.)
The author also takes the discussion across the world. In Africa, he meets with a no-till advocate. In Asia, society has been returning human waste to the ground as fertilizer for many years. (Cities even sell their waste to farmers.) Even Tacoma sells processed sewage as fertilizer. Farmers in North Dakota have adopted no-till to significant success.

Monday, May 02, 2011

The Vertical Farm


I read a recent article about an "internal" farm over in Europe and was hoping to find out more in this book. Unfortunately, all I got was a bit of Utopian Urban Justice. The author thinks that "vertical farms" will appear in blighted urban areas, providing abundant well-paying jobs, and driving up real estate values. Oh, and by the way, they will also help feed the world.

The vertical farms will also be architectural wonders (like the apple store on 5th avenue) and people will clamor for one in their neighborhood. They would provide high quality, tasty vegetables for the local neighborhood. The government would provide the seed money to get the research off the ground, but then they would magically appear. Since all pests are controlled, there will be no need for pesticides. They will save most of their water, and even be a depository for treated waste-water.

It is all find and dandy, except for a few major gaping holes:
1) Why would they chose to go in the middle of an urban area? These are in essence vegatable factories. The big suburban office parks seem like the logical locations. After all, those areas are cheaper, and provide for easier trucking.
2) Economies of scale. If a small 1-acre "21st-century greenhouse" can provide food for a neighborhood, why not make a huge monstrosity of a building? Then the produce can be trucked all around.
3) If these are all they are cracked up to be, entrepreneurs would be starting them up. Money is money. Oh they wont make money? Well, why bother? Since they are envisioned to be "totally organic" that should make it even easier to turn a profit.
4) Pest control is to be carried out by keeping the environment totally pure. But quality of the produce is to be enhanced by "stressing" them enough to produce enough taste and beneficial compounds. A few problems here. Can we really have a totally sterile environment? And do we want to? The issue of waste processing could also cause public concerns. "Outside" organic farmers could easily mount a smear campaign comparing "wholesome" outside produce to sterile produce grown with sewage.
5) Workers. Why are these expected to be nice jobs? Even if a vertical farm overcomes obstacles to create an urban farm, labor will be an issue. A conventional farm may get migrants working for a small fraction of what the urban workers would demand. The urban workers could more easily unionize and further drive up the labor cost. That's nice for them, but not so nice for the farm trying to compete with others. Could the system change? Sure. However, it will most likely be the established farms that finally decide the smaller transport costs and image can compensate for the extra urban labor costs.

As to the actual biological and chemical processes, this book doesn't have much to say. Waste can be treated. Water can saved. Solar power can be used to provide light to help "power" the plants. (Hmm, reductionism. Weren't we already supposed to have chemical vitamin compounds that eliminated the need for food?) The sterile environment and decontamination room keeps out pests. The devil is in the details. Unfortunately, the details are not this book's forte.