Madame Bovary

Madame Bovary is the story of a bored young woman who wants more from her life. She engages in a number of hedonistic activities and a engages in various dishonest behaviors. Eventually things begin to unravel and she takes her own life. It can be a challenge to keep track of what is going on at first. However, it does start to tie together well at the end.

The Stoic Challenge: A Philosopher's Guide to Becoming Tougher, Calmer, and More Resilient

Stoic Challenge is a short introduction to stoicism. Stoics are not immune to emotion. However, they view setbacks as growing experiences. Stoics acknowledge that we are often more negatively impacted by our response to a setback than the setback itself. We get angry at others that led to our set back - even when there is little that can be done now. If instead, we just take them as a growing experience, we are able to move on much more quickly from the setback. By not wasting effort at getting mad, we can move on more quickly and be happier.

The Anatomy of Peace: Resolving the Heart of Conflict

The Anatomy of Peace uses a story to illustrate how we can achieve inner peace regardless of what is going on externally. Often our approach is to try to "change others". However, this will usually fail if we are treating them as objects to change rather than as people with particular needs. The book uses a case study to explain the process. An executive and his wife are having struggles with his relapsed drug-addicted son. They send him to a wilderness camp run by an Arab and an Israeli. However, there is a two day parent session at the start where they meet together. In this session they talk about how they have got along and realized their challenges. They had each grown up hating the other's group, in spite of knowing people on "the other side". They had lost family in the conflict and become hardened and desired nothing other than defeating the other side. However, they each meet somebody that helps them make the transition to peace. They find it too late to make amends to their "dropped friends". However, the process of reaching out and attempted to make peace help them. The executive realizes that he has been treating others as "objects" rather than people. His interactions with his son are often done in anger in an attempt to correct him. He doesn't treat him as a person. Their relationship is part of the problem. He also has a similar issue with his employees. His first attempts at making peace with others fails miserably. He requires more effort to try to think of people outside of the box and as real people. He gradually does make changes.
Some of the lessons here are directly applicable to current events. Political discourse and protests today often come with a strong us against them viewpoint. People see a wrong and want other people to change. They see others as objects with the "wrong" viewpoint or actions. Any "changes" that the other side does are often fleeting. They are doing it out of fear, rather than need. The "oppressed" are quickly turning to "oppressing" others when given the chance. Instead, everyone needs to get on the same level and make peace to make a better world. This is much harder, but will make for better results.

Phule Me Twice: Phule's Company, Book 4

The fourth Phule's Company books continues with many of the same sitcom-esque humorous episodes. The General keeps trying to get Phule's Company to fail. The company has been asked to be military advisors to the Zenobians. This time he sends a major out to whip them into shape. However, he ends up going crazy and leaving. There is a robot Phule who is kidnapped from a casino, but ends up on the base. There are a group of people who join an "Elvis church" and alter their appearance to look like Elvis. Even robot-proof camouflage plays a role. In the end Phule makes peace between the Zenobians and a mysterious other species and the general falls flat on his face, all while many funny things happen in the interim.

Too Like the Lightning: Terra Ignota, Book 1

Too Like the Lightening is set in a futuristic world. A general peace is established with various "clans" that have differing views of the world. A high-speed transportation system is available that lets people go just about anywhere. Religion is taboo and having three are more people talk about religion is considered a church. Gender is considered archaic with most people considered gender neutral. Sexual activity is still a thing and the mere concept of gendered talk or dress is often found to be sexually promiscuous. The past is well respected in this world and the story is told often from an 18th century style of language. There are also computer-like people that are more machine than man.
While this utopian dystopia of a future world is built up in great detail, the story itself is somewhat confusion. There is a murderer who kills people in various ways. There are some conflicts between the groups. There are toy soldiers that are animated. Killings of seemingly insignificant people are used to alter the course of world events through their association with others. (In some ways it seems similar to current events.) It gets confusing.

Kitchen Mysteries: Revealing the Science of Cooking (Arts and Traditions of the Table: Perspectives on Culinary History)

Kitchen Mysteries is a well done, detailed book on the science behind what we do in the kitchen. Many parts are explained in detail. The author explains the science of letting batter "sit" and of how different leavening helps bread to rise. The details of a microwave cooking are explained as well as areas where it is most beneficial. Hot water freezes faster than cold water. Egg whites are mostly water. Using a cold copper bowl allows them to whip faster. A little yolk will interfere with the whipping, but is not a necessarily death sentence. Opening the oven while baking may kill it. For bread, he even suggests heating the oven to 500 degrees, then turning off after putting it in. (Though since this is a French book, this is probably more for a baguette.) There are some areas where the author admits he doesn't know. There may have been experiments done, but no conclusive results were found.
Cooking "science" is interesting in part because it has been practiced for many years without going through the scientific process. Science has started to catch up. However, many areas have been well established by practice. Most of the practices will have a scientific explanation. However, there are some that may have been established earlier, but are carried out in spite of changes that make them not so relevant. This book was written by a French author, so some of the concerns and details are not as relevant to the American kitchen. (Cakes in particular are quite different.) However, what is there is very thoroughly documented and explained.

Eating History: Thirty Turning Points in the Making of American Cuisine (Arts and Traditions of the Table: Perspectives on Culinary History)

Eating history is a collection of 30 vignettes covering key points in the evolution of American food. Each story also includes a brief "where are they now" postscript. Many of the "change artists" became rich and had companies that outlasted them, while some did not.
Early advancements in milling helped transform flour production from a purely local operation to something that could be handled in a centralized location. The Erie canal helped usher in improved transportation. This further consolidated milling. Technology for preserving and canning food also improved. By the time of the civil war canned food was one of the primary rations. This also led to a more general homogenization of American cuisine. Interestingly, the south earlier had a very diverse cuisine due in part to slavery. The slaves were given plots of land to grow crops to supplant their rations. They also did a lot of the cooking for their masters. This led to them bringing some flavors from their homeland.
Innovations like the reaper, fertilizer and genetic engineering helped encourage large scale industrial farms. On the other hand, muckrakers like Upton Sinclair and organic advocates like Rodale pushed back on food industrialization. Cook books and cooking shows have become very popular, spawning "celebrity chefs". Today there is also a great deal of consolidation in the food production world.
The thirty points do a great job of covering food history. There are probably many other key figures and events that could be included, but these are sufficient to paint a good picture of where we are now.

A Phule and His Money: Phule's Company Series, Book 3

In A Phule and His Money, Phule's company continues to work on the casino. They face many forces trying to break them down. They also get new recruits. Then they are given a new assignment to help help keep peace is in a civil conflict. This just happened to be the place where Phule caused problems early in his career. The planet was a former mining colony that now is known for roller costers. With Phule's help, they develop two great roller coaster parks and resolve the conflict. It is interesting how the "space future" was viewed in 1999. Simple things that we take for granted (like cell phones) would have made significant changes in how events would have unfolded.

The Rise and Fall of Ancient Egypt

Egypt has a long history. It existed as a continuous political entity for millennia before being absorbed by Rome a little over two thousand years ago. The kingdom generally confined itself to the Nile region. The "upper" and "lower" parts of Egypt would occasionally be separated, but would often be together. The Greeks came in and started ruling near the "end". However, they would adopt many of the Egyptian customs and continue ruling Egypt as Egypt. It was not until time time of Caesar that Rome eventually took over Egpyt and ended the period of self-rule.
Toby Wilkinson presents the history of Egypt as a chronological narrative. The focus is on Egypt and the leaders. Those that we know more about are covered in greater detail. Otherwise, the narrative may skip a few hundred years of history we know little about. The narrative does a good job of bringing in the key events that connect to the outside world. I liked the way the Rosetta stone popped out. The results of a minor campaign just happened to be inscribed in multiple languages, giving us a translation key. For the biblical Exodus, there was no specific Egyptian record. However, the author posits that a period of heavy imported labor may have been when it occurred.
The leaders of Egypt engaged in one-upmanship, building different large tombs and monuments. They were sometimes viewed as gods, while other times they were anointed by gods. Lines were generally hereditary, until they were not. Leaders were mostly men, except when they were women. There was a strong cult of the afterlife, leading to elaborate funeral practices (including mummies and pyramids.) However, it was also common for rulers to dismantle previous structures for their own monuments.
Egypt was a fascinating place. We know very little about the long history. Yet, we probably know more than we know of many other places so long ago.

Ingredients: The Strange Chemistry of What We Put in Us and on Us

Ingredients takes a popular scientific approach to analyzing what we eat. A good deal of the text analyzing the vexing question of why there is so much "garbage" out there about nutrition. It seems every day there is press coverage of some food being surprisingly healthy or unhealthy. This is often a result of the process of research. Subjects are often asked to recall what they had to eat and memories are not fully accurate. Even portions and exact contents may differ from person to person. There is also the matter of correlation. There are many different foods and lifestyle factors that contribute to overall health. A high fiber diet may be correlated with cancer simply because older people are more likely to be on a high fiber diet and have cancer. This does not mean that the diet causes cancer. The variables would need to be separated and controlled to get a more accurate picture.
Another problem is the nature of research. Publishing a study that says "chocolate doesn't protect against cancer" would not get much press coverage. However, one that found a connection would. Scientists are more likely to publish the novel findings. The nature of human populations and statistical flukes mean many of these findings could be found "significant" but not necessarily "real".
An ideal study would be tightly controlled. However, these are very difficult to do and may have ethical concerns. There have been some attempts. In one study, people brought groups of people into a hospital setting and fed some processed food and others unprocessed food. Then the diet was switched. The groups could eat as much as they wanted of each, and the food was set to be a somewhat similar caloric density. The participants claimed that each diet was equally tasty. However, those eating the processed food tended to eat more and gain more wait. This seems to say that processed food will cause us to gain weight. However, there could be other factors missed. If both tasted the same, why did they eat more of the processed food? Was there a "halo" effect involved? Was there something about the participants that made it less applicable?
All food contains chemicals. More processed foods often tend to be similar in structure. We need to eat chemicals to survive. Understanding what is best is a complex question. Simply avoiding one thing or another may be useful for one person, while detrimental to another. Food science is hard.

Scorpion Mountain: Brotherband, Book 5

The fifth brotherband book has the brotherband team engaging more closely with the Ranger's Apprentice team. They visit the castle and meet the King and princess. Hal invents spectacles to help a team member. The team travels to a desert land to try to lift an assassin cult's death sentence on the princess. They build a "land sail" to travel across the sand. They defeat the bad guys, complete there adventure and make it back safely. It is all the typical story. There is just enough conflict to keep things interesting, but you know that the good guys will win in the end.

The Goldfinch

Goldfinch centers on the life of a New York City boy, Theodore Decker who loses his mother in a museum explosion. He is with his mom, dreading a visit to the principal's office. However, they decide to visit a museum and his life changes. There is an explosion. His mom dies. An old man gives him a ring on the way out and he decides to take a painting. His dad had previously left his family, leaving him a ward of the state. He remembers an elementary school friend and goes to live with them. He also traces down the partner of the guy that gave him the ring and becomes friends with him. (He is also attracted to the girl that was with the old man.) He learns about the antiques business. Months later, his alcoholic, gambler dad picks him up and takes him to Vegas. He is pretty much left alone. He befriends Boris who also lives with his rarely present father. They have a lot of fun drinking and taking drugs.
Theodore's father has some gambling issues and dies after driving drunk. Theodore decides to go back to New York, and ends up going back to the antiques man. The story skips past his time in college and has him back working in the antique shop. He puts things in order financially by passing off remakes as antiques. He has a few chance encounters, discovers his childhood friend is dead and eventually becomes engaged. He runs into Boris, goes to Europe, gets the stolen painting back, kills some people, and loses the painting. He is on the brink of suicide, then decides to turn himself in. Just then Boris appears. He has collected money for reporting the location of the painting (and also uncovering others.) He uses the money to fix the antique fakes, calls off the engagement, and then pontificates at the end of the novel.
The novel is set in the hear and now and attempts to be realistic. However, there are just too many coincidences. There are so many "chance encounters" in Manhattan. Most seem to happen right when needed. Boris seems to come out of nowhere exactly when he is most needed in Theodore's life. The boys also seem to get along pretty well when they are inebriated, yet others get knocked out. You could just about call it "magical realism", except the "magical" is mostly coincidental. The end of the novel also goes on with some random thoughts that seem out of character with the rest of the novel. The story is a "coming of age" for a boy that seems to lose everything again and again, but still manages to bounce back. There is also a bit about art.

The Key to Creation

The Key to Creation brings the Terra Incognita series to a satisfying conclusion. The two warring groups have an experience that is closely modeled after the Arab/Israeli conflict. Or perhaps even the Suni/Shiite division. Each group is descended from a brother. Their relgious histories are similar, however, they bicker over the minor differences. Each side sees the other as heretics. They see similar areas as holy, yet they constantly fight against each other. The devout religious leaders are more concerned with their dogma than the truth. When a religious leader sees evidence that contradicts his religious understanding, he destroys it.
The main threads of the story finally connect and wind down in this final novel. The two warring factions have a huge battle with great destruction. Two expeditions both succeed in finding the source of their society. They awake the "father" of the founders of all their religions. He and his fellow beings are worshiped as gods. However, he admits that there are others with more power than him. He uses some of his technology to quickly return to the site of the great battle and help order peace. Both sides reverence him and finally put aside their differences. It is with great difficulty that they do this. They also maintain some of the keys to their respective religious, merging their established iconography, rather than than destroying it. Could this be a possible template for middle eastern peace? (Though it may be difficult to get Abraham to come back to order it.) Endless tit-for-tat revenge seeking will never be appeased.

Phule’s Paradise: Phule's Company Series, Book 2

The second Phule's company book has the motley crew being sent on a "punishment" mission to try to protect a casino. The owner is a young heir who is in over his head. He inadvertently leans on the very people that are trying to take over his operation to help him out. Phule hires some actors to help supplant his band, while sending others undercover as hotel employee. A crime boss, Maxine, owns all the other casinos and nearly has control of the this one before Phule outfoxes her. However, she is sneaky as him and sets things up for a longer term battle. It is yet another funny episode in this "sitcom in a book".

Snapshot

Snapshot by Brandon Sanderson

A Snapshot is a "replay" of a past point in time. A couple of "real detectives" can go back into the snapshot to observe what happened. However, since they are active participants, they can create "deviations" from the actual events. The snapshot computers provide a fully accurate replay of a small region. They also are able to calculate the degree of "change" that occurred in the snapshot. However, only "real people" in the snapshot can observe the details. The real people can also suffer and die within the snapshot. They can't really bring anything out of the snapshot. (Though they may be able to swallow something.) There are also plenty of privacy concerns with Snapshots. They can only be explored under warrant. The snapshot detective positions are low prestige, and typically takes those with minimal other opportunities. In a Snapshot, however, they are near omnipotent. They can flash a "snapshot" badge which lets people know they are in a snapshot, causing interesting reactions.

The Snapshot story follows two partners who are on duty to try to hunt for a murder weapon. They are able to find that, and then are told to stay in a safe house while waiting to explore a domestic violence incident. However, rather than do that, they explore another case of a serial killer that seems to be working around snapshot detectives. They also take time to visit family including one detectives non-custodial child. Things take a few turns, and we also end up with a Snapshot in a Snapshot and a few murder cases being resolved.

The snapshot is an intriguing structure. The story explores a lot of the concerns and abuses. It is also set as a "one burst of technology" in the near term future. There is a great deal of opportunity to explore this technology in future work.

The Global Achievement Gap: Why Even Our Best Schools Don't Teach the New Survival Skills our Children Need - and What We Can Do About it

Tony Wagner became disillusioned with the education system after spending time working as a teacher and administrator. In Global Achievement Gap, he identifies the problem with the education system and proposes solutions. He levels significant criticism at the "testing system." High stakes tests that are required for graduation have encouraged teachers to teach towards the test. Alas, the tests are created in a way that makes them easy to grade. This results in kids spending time learning facts rather than how to think. AP classes are also geared towards the test, with students required to memorize a great breadth of material rather then truly understand it. The importance of SAT and ACT tests also creates significant problems.
Testing is just one of the problems teachers face. There are many attempts at "education reform" that appear. Teachers are often presented with the "improvements of the day." The application of these new ideas takes time, but rarely sticks. Teachers become accustomed to going through the motions, knowing that these ideas will fade in a while. There are also "standardized curriculums" such as those in Now Child Left Behind. Teachers become "drones" instead of educators.
Teachers also receive minimal feedback. Administrators are overworked with responsibilities. Evaluations are perfunctory. Rather than look at learning experience, the evaluation focuses on completing a few "required actions." Even when outcomes are taken into account, the outcomes are based on "testing" rather than on actual learning.
What can be done? The author did have good things about the IB curriculum. This includes more detailed writing experiences and discussions on the theory of knowledge. Teachers also need greater feedback in their work. Instead of being isolated in the classroom, teachers should have more opportunity to work with other teachers and learn how to improve their teaching. Teaching itself should focus on students learning rather than recall. Writing and expressing thoughts should be stressed rather than recalling knowledge. Creativity is also important. Learning should also take into account the real world and students' desires for learning. The changes would make it more difficult to provide "standardized evaluation." However, it would result in students really learning rather than "going through the education system."

Phule's Company: Phule's Company, Book 1

Phule's Company is a band of misfit space legion recruits led by an ultra-wealthy heir to a Phule company munitions fortune. (Though Phule claims to have earned his money himself.) The legion does not know what to do with him. Rather than kick him our, the send him to be in charge of a remote outpost where nobody wants to be. There he manages to build up the esteem of his group and transform them into a viable fighting force. He always seems to know how to use bureaucracy and rules to his advantage. (Though padding things with some money doesn't hurt.) The rise is not perfect, but they are eventually able to use cunning to tie an elite army group in a contest of abilities. At the end, there is an alien visitation on the outpost. They manage to diffuse the conflict, and Phule gets rich through some business negotiations with them. It all seems very similar to a typical rags to riches sitcom.

Slaves of Socorro: Brotherband, Book 4

Slaves of Socorro is a "standalone" Brotherband book that starts to tie in more closely with the Ranger's Apprentice series. The crew of the Heron set out on their first mission. They are to be the treaty duty ship for an Araluen treaty. They also discover that their former brotherband nemesis has turned rogue. They give him chase, but he gets away. They meet up with a Ranger who wants them to go see the King. However, they end up going to a slave port to try to rescue some people that were taken in slavery. There is a lot of death and destruction, but all the good guys survive. The team also adopts a big dog that comes in handy to save the day. It was surprising that they just let a whole ship full of their nemesis sink. (Though they did have to be cajoled into not saving them.) The various talents of the team members continue to come in handy as they complete their adventures.

Missing Microbes

Microbes have existed long before we have and make up a greater share of living biomass than their "larger" counterparts. Two bacteria may be much more genetically different than a human and a tree. These organisms occupy just about every possible environment, including within the human body. The microbes are responsible for a great deal of human functionality, both good and bad. Alas, widespread use of antibiotics has pushed things out of whack. These drugs indiscriminately attack microbes, killing off the bad and the good. However, microbes evolve rapidly, thus allowing antibiotic resistant microbes to dominate. Widespread use of antibiotics helps "favor" the antibiotic-resistant strains, making our miracle cures less viable. There is a widespread tendency for doctors to prescribe antibiotics even when an infection would likely not respond to antibiotics. After all, if there is only a 1% chance of this drug helping, they should use it, right? Unfortunately, this logic leads to over-prescription and makes it more likely that the resistant strains develop, making the drugs useless for the people that really need it.
In addition to killing of the bad, the microbes also kill the good. This may be leading to a large number of different maladies, from asthma to allergies to obesity. Research is only in its early stage. However there are some connections visible now. Other practices have lead to a decreased amount of micro-biota present. C-section bearths reduce the pickup of microbes through the birth canal. Antibiotics fed to animals enter our food supply. Microbes cause ulcers. However, the absence of them may also be a contributing factor in other conditions. Many digestive issues seem to have a close relationship with microbes. (Alas "probiotics" are totally unregulated, so it is difficult to know what is good or bad.) Autism may also be related to microbes.
We have a synergistic relationship with our personal microbes. We should think twice before randomly killing them off.

A Reaper at the Gates (An Ember in the Ashes Book 3)

I thought this was the final book in the Ember in the Ashes series. It did seem to wrap things up, however it did it in a very unsatisfying way. The evil ones always seem to be a step ahead of the good guys. The characters are primarily in hard-core "war" mode. There is little time for caring for others. Often time spent loving others causes more negative than good. The struggle of the boy that is the "Reaper in training" is especially prescient. He must learn to not love others in order to use his magic to "reap" the dead into the after life. His failure to let go of love to others led him to neglect his duties, and with that neglect he gave enemies a chance to hurt his friend.
There are numerous times when the "good guys" seem on the cusp of "winning", but then bad things happen. The book continues to focus on two main girls and one boy as they work on their own goals that become interrelated in different ways. In the end, they all seem to fail. It makes for an ending that wraps things up, yet begs for more.

Transparent

Transparent centers around the life of an invisible girl, Fiona. She was dropped on her head as a baby because nobody could see her. She was one of many children born with unique "defects" cause by their parents use of a radioactive drug. The drug has been heavily restricted, but has a huge black market following. Her brothers also have powers (flying and smells.) Her father is the leader of a crime syndicate, and he uses his children to help out in nefarious efforts. (Fiona's invisibility makes her a great spy. Once she removes her clothes, nobody can tell where she is. She can also hide things in her mouth to make them invisible.)
Fiona and her mother have had enough and try to escape. She enrolls in a school in small town Arizona, and then struggles as a fish out of water. Some of her friends have powers also. All of the typical big-city girl in small town tropes apply. She makes friends with a girl in a big Catholic family and a smart boy and his brother. Fiona's brothers also appear to help her (though she thinks her "flying" brother is there to hurt her.) It is hard to keep track of all the different characters - especially the boys. Fiona struggles with her feelings towards a boy - even more so after she discovers that he can see her. Eventually they make peace and the family manages to defeat the charming father.
The book is a very "chick-lit" take on super heroes. Not much time is spent going into details about the society or the science of the story. (That is a good thing - there are so many holes in the scenario, that even spending a little time would detract from the experience.) The book provides a literal take on the figurative story of the girl that nobody can see finally finding the boy that sees her for what she is.

The Map of All Things: Terra Incognita, Book 2

Two groups of people descended from the same original group. However, they have adopted different customs and religions and absolutely hate each other. Hot heads on both sides continually lead to an escalation of tensions. One guy tries to make his royal fiance happy by massacring people in a religious site. This leads to the other side killing the Queen's brother. Needless to say, the queen is not happy, and leads another attack. This goes on and on. The people have so much animosity that they just can't get along. Religion is very important, but becomes a differentiator rather than a uniter.
Meanwhile, there is a quest that has gone on to map and find key sites. Alas, violence and religious fanaticism continues to get in the way. There are also spies that are weeded out by their ability to read text, as well as a girl who sneaks on to a ship disguised as a man. And then there is the assassin who becomes an informant. It all makes for a very crazy society.

The Warlock (The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel Book 5)

In this books, the twins are separated. They are each on different sides of a battle royal for the future (and past) of the earth. More historical figures keep popping up and intersecting with mythological characters. They also discover that many of their family members are more than it seems. Things take place less in the "here and now" than in the other books as time and geography become fluid. How will the final book end?

Deadliest Enemy: Our War Against Killer Germs

Michael Osterholm wrote "Deadliest Enemy" a few years ago to warn against the dangers of infectious disease. There have been a number of cases of disease outbreaks that have sparked immediate action (SARS, MERS, Zika, Ebola). However, once the disease is contained the interest fades. Significant research is performed initially. However, funding goes away after the threat fades, leaving incomplete results. Even diseases like Malaria get brushed off as "third world" diseases, and little effort is spent on containing them.
We have also reached a level of complacency with the seasonal flu. The annual vaccine provides a steady revenue stream. However, getting it every year may provide less immunity than receiving it occasionally. We have also stalled on achieving a "permanent" vaccine. Like other vaccines, the financial component may be getting in the way of some research.
Many of the novel viruses transfer from animals to humans in areas where they live close together. Third world megacities are especially vulnerable. Mosquitos are also primary vector for other diseases.
In one section, he describes a flu pandemic which sounds earlier like the current Covid-19 pandemic. Alas, we have still not prepared for it.

Most Likely to Succeed: Preparing Our Kids for the New Innovation Era

Our current education is stuck in the past. There is an excessive emphasis on the memorization of facts and the application of formulas. These are things that are easy to test on standardized tests. This may have been useful in past centuries where knowledge was difficult to obtain. However, now most everybody carries a device that allows access to vast stores of knowledge and the easy computation. This leaves much of what is learned in school useless. Most students forget the knowledge learned. (In one example, they tested students at the start of the next school year on a "dumbed-down" version of the final exam. The scores went from Bs to Fs.) Today, the problem is not obtaining knowledge, but being able to properly evaluate and discern the truth. People need to be able to do, not know. (A funny example was given of "bicycle riding" and a Bicycle Aptitude Test. We could easily test that students have esoteric knowledge of bicycles, but that is not useful when it comes to riding.)
I'm reminded of the case where a Chemical Engineering department was concerned about the lack of language proficiency of its (mostly non-native English speaking) students. However, most of the foreign students passed the test, while the native English speakers were stuck in "remedial English" classes. Some people had "test knowledge" of English but couldn't communicate, while others could communicate, but couldn't pass the test.
The argument here is starkly different from many education reformers and education apologists. We can let other countries excel at tests. What we need are more creative thinkers. Teachers are doing a horrible job in part because of the system they are in. Most of the skills learned in school are irrelevant. Lecture courses are largely irrelevant these days. Instead education should be focused on helping students to learn. Multiple choice tests are easy to grade and fit people to a curve, but they just don't help. We should not deny students resources available. Don't teach towards the test. Let people learn what interests them. It is almost an "unschooling" within a school that is advocated. It is time to stop 19th century education in the 21st century.