Showing posts with label Barry Press. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barry Press. Show all posts

Friday, June 20, 2025

A Nation Without Borders: The United States and Its World in an Age of Civil Wars, 1830-1910

A Nation Without Borders: The United States and Its World in an Age of Civil Wars, 1830-1910 by Steven Hahn

From 1830 to 1910, the United States underwent great changes. At the start it was mostly a small agglomeration of rural residents that valued their independence. After many conflicts, the Us emerged in the early 20th century as a unified country that was a significant player on the international stage.

This book is a focussed, yet broad history. There are many histories of small periods, such as the civil war. There are also many covering the entire history of the United States. This focus of an extended time of change is much more rare. There is probably a reason why. This book feels like it is telling a number of different stories without a strong theme tying things together. The author tries, but a theme of "change" is a little tough. In some ways it is a Civil War book, with clear context of the history leading to the war as well as the results after the war.

Sunday, February 13, 2022

The Gluten Lie: And Other Myths About What You Eat

Fat is bad. Gluten is bad. Sugar is bad. MSG is bad. Every day we seem to see a story about some food that is "bad". We are encouraged to avoid it. Or perhaps we are encouraged to adopt a diet like Paleo, Vegan, Gluten free or something else. These often have advocates. There are people that have success with them. There are also people that do not.

Gluten is an interesting case. Some people do have celiac disease. For them, gluten is very bad. However, for most other people it is not. Earlier, a banana diet was seen as a cure for celiac disease. It worked - because it eliminated gluten as a side effect. However, once the banana relation was removed, low-gluten diets faded. This left gluten out of our minds eye. As gluten has roared back, it has helped people with undiagnosed celiac. However, it has hurt many other people that have adopted low gluten diets that do not benefit them.

Isolated studies often get great publicity. There may be advocates that repeat the findings in the media. This gives the impression that it is commonly accepted - even if there is little scientific basis. People end up yo-yoing around trying to find the latest fad. They may actually feel bad due to a placebo (or nocebo) effect. This distracts as from the important behaviors that will improve health. The villain keeps changing. Sugar and salt each get coverage. Some extreme diets (such as the rice diet) were also covered. 

In the end, he makes a "diet" suggestion. The first is to just not diet. Detox by avoiding reading anything about nutrition for a month. Focus on eating food you like. Don't keep track of it. But, spend time to eat. Devote time to sit down and eat. Don't do any activity while eating (expect perhaps talking to others.) Enjoy varied cuisines. This all seemed good.

Then he went off the deep end. He declared packaging and plastics to be a source of most of our problems. We have become fatter, even after eating "healthy" in various ways. So it must be all the plastics. After all, people would use glass jars previously. At first I thought this was tongue and cheek. However, it did feel real. He trained me in the previous chapters to question studies - especially when they advocated a quick fix. Now he was advocated a quick fix. What? 

What should we do? Eat a variety of food. Don't expect any food to be a panacea. Look for bias in studies. Everyone can have an opinion. There may also be bias in what is thought to be "good". (For example, a study looked at sedentary behavior watching TV and playing video games, but not reading. Aren't they all just as sedentary?) Even the author showed biases in how he reported about biases. When it comes to eating, it is best to eat food you enjoy, but not too much of it. If it makes you sick, you probably should not eat it.

Tuesday, October 06, 2020

The Math Myth: And Other STEM Delusions

Despite the title, the Math Myth is actually pro math. However, it enunciates many concerns with the way that math is taught and used as a "weed out". Most students are required to take standard math classes. These classes are often taught by adjunct professors, because the full professor do not want to teach them. This leaves most students exposed to mediocre math instruction and has also led to a decline in those studying math. The courses have also "weeded out" many students who would otherwise be able to complete degrees.

Math is critically import to society today. Calculus underpins much of our advanced technology. Due to complex mathematical calculations, we have airplanes, microchips, cell phones and most things we take for granted today. However, only a very small number of people are actually using the advanced math in their work. Even in the development of advanced technology, there may be only a handful of people that need to know math beyond basic algebra. And even for this math, people are rarely solving them "the way they did in school." Most of the work is done by a computer. 

What can be done? Practical math and arithmetic can be stressed in school. There is a need to understand basic financial transactions as well as other things that are encountered in daily life. Statistics is also highly valuable. Advanced math has its place, but an emphasis should be on understanding rather than solving equations that a computer could solve. The advanced math should also be made more appropriate to the study. Why not have a math course taught by a psychologist? If psychologists need math, a psychologist may be better able to teach the practical math than a mathematician. Courses in math related courses (such as statistics) may be much more valuable for some fields of study. Math should not prevent students from entering their careers.