Showing posts with label Derek Parfit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Derek Parfit. Show all posts

Friday, March 06, 2026

On What Matters: Volume Three

On What Matters: Volume Three by Derek Parfit

The philosophy in the book is interesting, but the writing is tedious. There is a huge summary at the start that goes into great detail. The actual work is only slightly more in depth than the summary. Much of it is in response to responses of other philosophers. I felt like I was eavesdropping on some private conversations. Much of the work discusses ethical situations and the practical applications. People are reluctant to cause harm to somebody even if it reduces harm to more people. However, people tend to be ok performing an action that has a side effect of harm. These ethics can lead to greater overall harm. (As an example, nuking 100,000 people would be considered worse than a demonstration of a powerful nuclear bomb - even if that bomb would result in 300,000 people dying of nuclear fallout.) Similarly a longer episode of military bombing is preferable to direct civilian bombing - even if more civilians die in the military bombing. People end up not being fully rational. 

Other arguments get into the weeds of philosophy, such as what it means to refer to something. There is also discussions of effective altruism and efficient desire to donate to charities. Philosophy proves out some of the strange contradictions in humans.

Wednesday, March 05, 2025

Reasons and Persons

Reasons and Persons by Derek Parfit

This is a long book that explores ethics and morals. What makes something ethical? Sometimes there appear to be simple situations. Then there are complex situations. The temporal dimension adds many challenges. Would you do something now that negatively impacted you of the future? Can you complain about those of the past since you would not be there without them? What should you do for the future? How does this differ from impacts of other people? There are challenges with many different philosophical theories.

A big section of the book explores science fiction topics. What entails your identity? If you have a device that transfers you to a different place by reading your body and reassembling it elsewhere, is that new person you? What if both the old and new are maintained? What if there are small changes made to you?  There are challenges for multiple definitions of "sameness"

There are a number of interesting arguments here, though it does go on for a long time.



Thursday, November 23, 2023

Parfit: A Philosopher and His Mission to Save Morality

Parfit is a well written biography that does a great job painting the life of Derek Parfit. He was somewhat of a child prodigy. Born in China of British parents engaging in missionary-related work, he had a somewhat privileged upbringing. He did well in school and had his share of youthful craziness. He went through some academic processes. (The details would have been clearer to those familiar with the British school system.) He was able to study in America and eventually switched to philosophy. He had characteristics of those on the autism spectrum (aspergers)  He would be a perfectionist in his writing, even complaining about font spacing. He also took time to comment on others work. 

The book complains that he was an important moral philosopher, however, it was rather short on details. I did not get a strong picture of why. There were a few examples of philosophy, but the book seems to be geared towards a popular audience that already thinks of him as an important philosopher.